‘To Be Able to Identify the Mechanism Does Not Invalidate the Mechanism’ — Christopher Nolan Lays Out a ‘Fundamental Flaw’ With Amateur Film Criticism

← Back to the feed

‘To Be Able to Identify the Mechanism Does Not Invalidate the Mechanism’ — Christopher Nolan Lays Out a ‘Fundamental Flaw’ With Amateur Film Criticism

IGN · 6 hours ago

Christopher Nolan has criticised what he calls a "fundamental flaw" in amateur film criticism, arguing that identifying the storytelling techniques a film uses does not make those techniques invalid. Speaking in a podcast interview with host Zhong Shu, the director said audiences often dismiss emotional or narrative devices simply because they can recognise how those devices work, which he sees as a misunderstanding of how storytelling functions. The comments come as his July release The Odyssey continues to draw mixed reactions, giving the remarks added weight amid ongoing debate about the film.

Nolan explained that storytelling is a "lingua franca" built by Hollywood over the past century, with conventions that can be bent or broken but must still be understood. He clarified that his criticism targets amateur commentators rather than professional critics, who he believes better grasp the necessity of these narrative mechanisms. The remarks follow a pointed negative review of The Odyssey last week from Greek translator Emily Wilson, whom Nolan had previously referenced while promoting the film, and who said she would have been "ashamed" to have written any part of the script.

  • Nolan says spotting a film's storytelling tricks doesn't invalidate them
  • He blames "amateur" critics, not professional ones, for this flaw
  • Comments follow harsh reviews of his film The Odyssey, including from Emily Wilson

Entertainment Film

Read the full article at the source →