5 Ambitious Gothic Stories That Robert Eggers Should Adapt
This piece from Collider argues that director Robert Eggers, known for meticulous, historically grounded horror films such as *The Witch*, *The Lighthouse* and *Nosferatu*, is ideally suited to adapting Gothic literature. Since Eggers avoids contemporary settings and favours pre-World War II periods, the article proposes several classic and modern Gothic novels and stories it believes would suit his slow-burn, atmospheric style, matching his established taste for folklore, dread and historical detail.
Among the suggestions is Edgar Allan Poe's 1838 short story "Ligeia", an ambiguous tale of an opium-addicted narrator and his apparently resurrected first wife, which builds on Eggers' earlier short-film adaptation of Poe's "The Raven". Also highlighted is Christopher Buehlman's novel *Between Two Fires*, a brutal historical fantasy set during the 1348 Black Death in France, following a disgraced knight and a visionary girl. The article frames these as just two of five recommended works spanning Victorian classics and contemporary historical horror, all offering the kind of macabre, pre-modern settings Eggers has shown a strong preference for throughout his career.
- Collider suggests Gothic stories suited to director Robert Eggers' style
- Recommendations include Poe's "Ligeia" and Buehlman's *Between Two Fires*
- Eggers favours historical, pre-WWII settings over contemporary ones
New here? Start with this
Robert Eggers has built his reputation on horror films set firmly in the past, including The Witch, The Lighthouse and his recent take on Nosferatu, all praised for their obsessive historical detail, folklore-tinged dread and slow, unsettling pace. He has shown little interest in modern-day settings, favouring stories rooted in earlier centuries, which has led commentators to think about what other classic or "Gothic" literature might suit his style.
Gothic fiction is a genre built around old, decaying settings, family secrets, the supernatural and a sense of creeping horror, with roots going back to writers like Edgar Allan Poe. This piece is one writer's suggestion list, proposing works such as Poe's short story "Ligeia" and Christopher Buehlman's novel Between Two Fires as strong candidates for Eggers to adapt, based on how closely they match his established interests.
It is worth noting this is a speculative, opinion-led piece rather than an announcement of any actual project. Eggers has not confirmed involvement with any of the works mentioned; the article is simply matching his known artistic tendencies to existing books and stories.