Collider has published its ranking of every new Prime Video show to debut in the first half of 2026, ordering 12 titles from worst to best based on writing, performances and cultural impact. The list reflects a strong year for the streamer, which has released a mix of historical dramas, comic-book adaptations and reimaginings of familiar characters.

At the bottom of the ranking is "The Gray House", a historical drama executive produced by Kevin Costner and Morgan Freeman about four Southern women running a Civil War-era spy network, which the reviewer found overstuffed and melodramatic despite strong production values. Just above it sits "Kevin", an adult animated comedy from Aubrey Plaza and Joe Wengert about a neurotic housecat, described as a disappointing misfire despite its cast. The article's text was cut short before revealing the higher-ranked shows.