Glasner criticises VAR clarity after Forest’s disallowed goal at Spurs

← Back to the feed

Glasner criticises VAR clarity after Forest’s disallowed goal at Spurs

Developing story first seen 2 hours ago

The Guardian · 2 hours ago

Nottingham Forest head coach Oliver Glasner has escalated his criticism of VAR official Peter Bankes, saying the video review that disallowed Neco Williams's goalline header against Tottenham amounted to "guessing" rather than a clear and obvious decision, and warned that such interventions undermine referees' authority. The incident, which saw Williams's effort ruled out for an alleged handball as he headed in Morgan Gibbs-White's deflected shot, was the pivotal moment in an otherwise goalless and largely uneventful Premier League draw between two winless sides.

Glasner said he had studied five or six camera angles and while one suggested Williams's shirt moved slightly, it was unclear whether this was caused by the ball or by Sandro Tonali's attempted clearance, insisting the threshold for VAR intervention agreed before the season was not met. Referee Craig Pawson announced via pitchside microphone that the ball had touched Williams's hand before the goal, prompting boos from the home crowd, while Williams, who signed a new four-year contract this week, insisted he headed the ball "in between my arms" and it never clearly struck them. Tottenham, managed by Roberto De Zerbi, failed to register a shot on target for the third straight league match, extending their winless start, with both clubs now facing pivotal fixtures next weekend against Everton and Aston Villa respectively.

  • Glasner says VAR's Bankes was "guessing" on Williams's disallowed goal
  • Williams denies handball, says he headed it "in between my arms"
  • Match finished goalless; both Forest and Spurs remain winless

New here? Start with this

Nottingham Forest and Tottenham Hotspur are two Premier League clubs who have both struggled for form this season and had yet to win a league match going into this fixture. Forest are managed by Oliver Glasner, while Spurs are led by Roberto De Zerbi. VAR, or Video Assistant Referee, is the video review system used in the Premier League to check certain decisions, including handballs, and can overturn a goal if a clear infringement is spotted.

The key moment in this goalless draw came when Forest's Neco Williams headed the ball into the net, only for the goal to be disallowed after a VAR review suggested the ball had struck his arm. Handball decisions of this kind are often contentious because they can depend on fine margins, such as whether the ball or a defender's touch caused a player's shirt or arm to move, and on where the rules say a "clear and obvious error" threshold lies for VAR to intervene.

Disputes over VAR's role in English football are a recurring theme, with managers, players and pundits regularly debating whether the system is applied consistently and whether it should overrule on-field officials in marginal cases. This incident matters because it feeds into that wider ongoing debate, while also affecting two clubs under pressure to start winning matches as the season progresses.

More coverage

Football Sport

Read the full article at the source →

Originally published by The Guardian as “Glasner claims VAR was ‘guessing’ after Forest are denied winner against Spurs”.