India cockroach protests: Videos show officers firing ‘pellet guns’
Thousands of people have protested in Delhi, demanding education reforms and the resignation of a government minister. Videos analysed by BBC Verify appear to show security officers firing pellet guns towards demonstrators, raising concerns about the response to the protests and possible injuries.
The Central Reserve Police Force did not answer BBC Verify’s questions about the alleged use of pellet guns or protesters’ apparent injuries. It told Indian media that it was too early to comment and that it was investigating what happened.
- Thousands protest in Delhi over education reforms.
- Videos appear to show pellet guns fired at protesters.
- Police force says it is investigating the events.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of the protests argue that large demonstrations can be a legitimate response when students and families believe educational policy is failing them. They would say that the reported use of pellet guns against demonstrators is deeply concerning, because crowd-control measures should prioritise restraint and protect the right to peaceful protest.
The case against
Those defending the authorities’ position may argue that police have a duty to keep major demonstrations from becoming dangerous, disruptive or violent, particularly in a densely populated city. They would contend that officers may need proportionate means to disperse crowds when other measures fail, while stressing that any use of force should be necessary, lawful and independently scrutinised.