A TikTok-originated label, ‘indie poo’, is being used to describe formulaic British indie bands that echo earlier acts such as Arctic Monkeys, Oasis and The Strokes. The article argues that it largely repeats the older, dismissive idea of ‘indie landfill’, and questions whether broad genre labels fairly judge artists or simply make criticism of indie music more predictable.

While some newer bands may rely on familiar guitar riffs, vocal styles and working-class imagery to follow commercial trends, the article notes that imitation has always shaped popular music. It also argues that ‘landfill indie’ brought enjoyable, carefree music to many listeners, and that dismissing it as shallow overlooks its cultural value; ultimately, the writer finds ‘indie poo’ less insulting than unoriginal and reductive.