Miliband’s trade ban is in response to controversial settlement that risks killing off any hope of a two-state solution for Palestine
Britain's Jewish community has strongly criticised the Labour government's decision to impose trade sanctions on Israeli settlements in the West Bank, warning the move could embolden anti-Semites and extremists in the UK. Chief Rabbi Sir Ephraim Mirvis called it "a dark day for British Jews," while community leaders expressed anger that Prime Minister Andy Burnham pressed ahead despite "significant concerns" they had personally raised with him about the policy's "unintended consequences." Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband announced the sanctions in the Commons, prompting further anger over their timing, just before Rosh Hashanah and close to the anniversary of the Heaton Park synagogue attack in Manchester.
The sanctions come amid mounting international concern over Israeli settlement expansion, particularly plans to open tenders for 1,200 homes east of Jerusalem that would effectively divide the West Bank. Critics, including Labour peer Lord Mendelsohn and Tory peer Lord Polak, condemned Miliband's framing of the announcement, while the Board of Deputies of British Jews said it followed the news with "deep regret." Questions have also been raised about the timing ahead of Israeli elections next month, with the Jewish Labour Movement warning the move could strengthen hardline sentiment in Israel, since the policy will reportedly take six to nine months to implement.
- Labour imposes trade sanctions on Israeli West Bank settlements
- British Jewish leaders warn of rising anti-Semitism and "unintended consequences"
- Timing criticised ahead of Rosh Hashanah and Israeli elections
New here? Start with this
Britain has long had a small but well-established Jewish community, and its relationship with the Israeli government and West Bank policy has periodically caused friction with successive UK governments. The West Bank is territory that Israel has occupied since 1967, and Jewish settlements built there are considered illegal under international law by most of the world, though Israel disputes this. A "two-state solution" refers to the long-standing, though increasingly fragile, idea of an independent Palestinian state existing alongside Israel.
The key figures here are Ed Miliband, the Foreign Secretary who announced the trade restrictions on goods from Israeli settlements, and Prime Minister Andy Burnham, who backed the policy despite objections from Jewish community leaders. Sir Ephraim Mirvis, the Chief Rabbi, is the most senior rabbi in the UK and a prominent voice on issues affecting British Jews, while the Board of Deputies of British Jews is the community's main representative body. The Jewish Labour Movement is an affiliated Labour group representing Jewish members of the party.
This matters because it touches on several sensitive and interconnected issues: UK foreign policy towards Israel and the Palestinians, concerns about rising antisemitism in Britain, and debates over Israeli settlement expansion in the West Bank, which critics say undermines prospects for a future Palestinian state. The dispute also reflects wider tensions within the Labour Party over how to balance its foreign policy positions with relations with British Jewish communities.