# “Original Meaning and the Freedom of Speech and Press”: “Scant Evidence: Provoking a Riot”

- URL: https://talkfuse.com/story/original-meaning-and-the-freedom-of-speech-and-press-scant-evidence-provoking-a-riot/
- Published: 2026-11-20T13:01:11+00:00
- Updated: 2026-11-20T13:20:18+00:00
- Original publisher: Reason (publisher lean: Right)
- Original article: https://reason.com/volokh/2026/11/20/original-meaning-and-the-freedom-of-speech-and-press-scant-evidence-provoking-a-riot/
- Topics: Politics

## Key points

- A judge said an insulting effigy could be criminal if it risked provoking a breach of the peace.
- The 1824 case involved figures called a “Paddy” and a “Shelah”.
- The author says its relevance to modern speech debates is uncertain.

## Summary

In an 1824 Pennsylvania case, a judge told a jury that displaying an insulting effigy could be a crime if it was intended to provoke a group into breaking the peace. The article presents this little-discussed ruling as possible historical evidence about how early American law understood freedom of expression, a question with potential relevance to modern First Amendment debates.

The case involved a figure called a “Paddy”, displayed in a neighbourhood largely inhabited by Irish emigrants and resented as an insult to its Catholic residents. The defendant’s role in displaying that figure was disputed, though displaying a different figure, a “Shelah”, was not; the jury acquitted him. The author stresses that the evidence is scant and the case’s wider significance depends on whether the judge’s account reflected common law beyond Pennsylvania.

---
Summarised by TalkFuse (https://talkfuse.com/). Quote the original publisher for the reporting and link this page for the summary and discussion.
