Prime Video has ended 'It's Not Like That' after just one season, concluding the eight-episode run that debuted in January. The cancellation came despite the show's strong performance, spending roughly six weeks in Prime's top 10 and reaching as high as third place, alongside earning a perfect 100% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The faith-based drama centred on a recently divorced woman and widowed pastor navigating single parenthood.

Star Scott Foley shared his reaction through an Instagram video, acknowledging the disappointment whilst expressing gratitude to the cast, crew, and viewers who engaged with the series. He encouraged anyone who hadn't watched to still check it out on the platform and thanked supporters whether they discovered the show independently or through recommendations. The series was created by Ian Deitchman and Kristin Rusk Robinson and featured an ensemble cast including Erinn Hayes and J.R. Ramirez.