Sydney Swans stun reigning back-to-back premiers Brisbane by 53 points in massive SCG qualifying final boil over despite losing five of their best players to sexual assault scandal
Developed over time first seen 2 hours ago
Sydney Swans pulled off a major AFL finals upset, thrashing back-to-back reigning premiers Brisbane by 53 points in their qualifying final at the SCG, despite being without several key players due to a club sexual assault suspension and a first-quarter injury to captain Callum Mills. The result is significant because Sydney entered the match severely weakened, yet dominated all four quarters against a Lions side chasing a third consecutive premiership, propelling the Swans into a preliminary final at home.
Sydney won 21.15 (141) to 13.10 (88) in front of 37,261 fans, with Logan McDonald kicking a career-best six goals and Charlie Curnow and Tom Papley each adding five. Sydney will now host either Fremantle or Geelong in a preliminary final, while Brisbane return to the Gabba for a semi-final against the Western Bulldogs or Adelaide. The Swans were already missing vice-captain Isaac Heeney and teammates Chad Warner and Nick Blakey, among five players serving club-imposed suspensions linked to an alleged sexual assault at a Melbourne hotel on 17 August, and lost captain Mills to a likely ACL injury during the game.
- Sydney Swans thrashed reigning premiers Brisbane by 53 points at the SCG
- Win came despite five players suspended over sexual assault allegations
- Captain Callum Mills suffered a likely ACL injury; Swans advance to preliminary final
Full account
Sydney produced one of the more startling results of the AFL finals series, running out 53-point winners over reigning back-to-back premiers Brisbane in their qualifying final at the SCG. The Swans won 21.15 (141) to 13.10 (88) in front of 37,261 spectators, dominating every quarter against a Lions side that never found its rhythm. Forward Logan McDonald was the outstanding performer with six goals, while Charlie Curnow and Tom Papley each added five, with Errol Gulden influential through the midfield with 34 disposals.
The victory was made more remarkable by the circumstances surrounding it. Sydney captain Callum Mills went down with a suspected serious knee injury in the first quarter and will undergo scans to determine the extent of the damage, while the club was already missing several first-choice players, including vice-captain Isaac Heeney, Chad Warner and Nick Blakey, who are among five Swans players serving club-imposed suspensions. Despite the disruption, Sydney's depth proved more than sufficient, with James Rowbottom doing a strong defensive job on Brisbane star Lachie Neale and Oscar Allen the lone bright spot up forward for the Lions with four goals.
The suspensions stem from a serious off-field matter that has overshadowed the club's season. Chad Warner, Isaac Heeney, Riley Bice, Nick Blakey and James Jordon were among those in a hotel room at the Pullman in East Melbourne in the early hours of 17 August, an evening now at the centre of a Victoria Police investigation into alleged sexual assault. Reporting has since revealed detectives have obtained an audio recording from a Melbourne property said to contain accounts from people who were in the room, as well as details of interactions in the hotel lobby involving Swans staff, including coach Dean Cox. No charges have been laid, and it has not been suggested that any of the players were involved in wrongdoing; three other men present were interviewed only as witnesses, and police say they are not seeking anyone further in connection with the case. The Swans have declined to comment on the investigation or its implications for the players' futures, while insisting no club staff were present in the room itself.
With the investigation expected to run for at least another two months, Sydney's on-field success offers a stark contrast to the turmoil off it. The Swans progress straight to a preliminary final at the SCG against the winner of Fremantle and Geelong, continuing an improbable finals push shorn of key personnel. Brisbane, meanwhile, drop into a semi-final at the Gabba against either the Western Bulldogs or Adelaide, still well placed in their bid for a third consecutive premiership despite the heavy defeat.
Where outlets differ
The match report focuses almost entirely on the football contest itself and only briefly references the suspensions, naming three of the five sidelined players (Heeney, Warner, Blakey) without detail on the allegations.
The investigation report gives extensive detail on the scandal, naming all five suspended players (adding Riley Bice and James Jordon) and describing specific allegations, including the audio recording and coach Dean Cox's alleged presence in the hotel lobby — none of which appears in the match coverage.
The two reports use slightly different framing for the players' absence: the match report calls it 'club-imposed suspensions', while the investigation report specifies 'season-long suspensions' tied to a breach of 'expected club behaviour and standards'.
Only the investigation report notes that Victoria Police have already interviewed four of the five players and reclassified one as a witness, and that the case could take at least another eight weeks to conclude.
More coverage