The 1983 song Lemmy called everything “wrong with American rock”

← Back to the feed

The 1983 song Lemmy called everything “wrong with American rock”

Far Out · 57 minutes ago

Lemmy criticised Meat Loaf’s 1983 song ‘Razor’s Edge’, arguing that it represented everything wrong with American rock: polished, emotionally overstated and built around formula rather than genuine feeling. His comments mattered because he distinguished technical excellence from the danger, personality and authenticity he believed rock music required.

The song appeared after Meat Loaf’s split from songwriter Jim Steinman, whose dramatic vision had defined Bat Out of Hell. Although Lemmy acknowledged the flawless vocals and musicianship, he dismissed the track as “emotionally charged drivel”, contrasting its immaculate production with the roughness and individuality of Motörhead’s music. The article argues that Lemmy’s own successful ballads worked because they retained a recognisable human character.

  • Lemmy condemned ‘Razor’s Edge’ as polished but emotionally hollow.
  • Meat Loaf recorded it after separating from Jim Steinman.
  • Authenticity mattered more to Lemmy than technical perfection.

Music

Read the full article at the source →