Barney Ronay's Guardian column argues that while Thomas Tuchel will inevitably take the blame for England's World Cup semi-final exit to Argentina in Atlanta, the defeat reflects a deeper, recurring pattern in English football culture rather than being solely down to one manager's failings. The piece draws parallels with previous England exits under different managers, suggesting a familiar cycle of questionable selections and the team "shrinking" on the big stage, regardless of who is in charge.

The article focuses on the collapse between the 72nd and 92nd minutes, when Tuchel shifted England into a defensive back five after the team had already lost attacking shape and momentum. By the 82nd minute, England had six defenders on the pitch, reflecting a shift from ambition to fear. Ronay contrasts this tactical retreat with the pre-match talk of energy and courage, noting Tuchel appeared visibly strained afterwards while defending his decisions, even as he acknowledged that losing makes every choice look wrong in hindsight.