Wonder Man star Yahya Abdul-Mateen II has spoken publicly for the first time about the Marvel series being un-renewed by Disney+, telling Vanity Fair he was informed the decision related to viewership numbers, though he was not given specifics. The reversal is notable because Disney+ had renewed the show for a second season back in March before abruptly overturning that decision in late July, leaving the cast and fans blindsided.

The actor drew a poignant parallel between the cancellation and the show's own plot, in which his character Simon, an aspiring actor with hidden superpowers, strives for his big break only to see it slip away. Abdul-Mateen, who received an Emmy nomination for the role, said he remains proud of the work and had his own ideas for where Simon's story might have gone in a second season, exploring what happens once someone finally achieves their dreams. He also thanked fans on Instagram for embracing the show, calling its warm reception his favourite part of the experience.