Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Making Crazy Horse: The Role of a Lifetime
The article examines the long-running construction of the Crazy Horse Memorial in South Dakota, portraying it as an ambitious counterpart to Mount Rushmore and a tribute to Lakota leader Crazy Horse and Native American history. It argues that the project’s scale, history and persistence make it culturally significant, while acknowledging enduring questions over its completion, funding and the appropriateness of carving the mountain.
The memorial was proposed in 1939 by Oglala Lakota chief Henry Standing Bear and has been under construction since the first blast in 1948. Designed by sculptor Korczak Ziolkowski, it is planned to stand 563 feet high and 641 feet long; Crazy Horse’s 87-foot face was completed in 1998, but the wider work remains unfinished. The privately run non-profit has not accepted government funding, and Ziolkowski’s family continues to oversee the carving using modern surveying and cutting technology.
In short
- Crazy Horse Memorial remains an unfinished, privately funded mountain sculpture.
- The project began in 1948 and far exceeds Mount Rushmore in scale.
- Its cultural value and treatment of sacred land remain debated.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Chief Henry Standing Bear's 1939 proposal centred Lakota agency in commissioning their own monumental history, explicitly positioning Native Americans as authors rather than subjects. The memorial's refusal of government funding preserves Indigenous autonomy, whilst the completed face of Crazy Horse represents a world-class artistic achievement that commands global recognition of Native American history and generates economic benefits for Indigenous communities.
The case against
Critics question whether mountain carving authentically honours Lakota spiritual traditions, given many Indigenous cultures' reverence for natural landscapes as sacred. Crazy Horse famously resisted being photographed and opposed commodification, creating tensions between his documented values and a massive tourist monument. Critics further argue that eight decades of resource commitment might more directly serve contemporary Native American communities facing urgent challenges, and question whether the memorial's ongoing incompletion suggests the original vision remains unrealistic.
Explained simply
The Crazy Horse Memorial is a massive sculpture being carved into a mountain in South Dakota. Like Mount Rushmore, it aims to commemorate an important American figure and honour Lakota heritage, specifically the Lakota leader Crazy Horse.
The project began in 1939 when Oglala Lakota chief Henry Standing Bear proposed it, and carving started in 1948. Sculptor Korczak Ziolkowski designed the memorial to be 563 feet high and 641 feet wide, with only Crazy Horse's 87-foot face completed so far.
The memorial operates as a privately funded non-profit without government support, and Ziolkowski's family continues to oversee the work using modern surveying and cutting technology. The scale and complexity of the project, combined with its ongoing construction for over seven decades, have made it notable as a long-term tribute to Native American history.
Art Culture Entertainment Music Politics