News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
‘Road closures for fire are affecting my pub’s trade’
A pub landlord near Sheffield says he may have to lay off staff after a wildfire-related road closure cut off passing trade. Steve Marsh, owner of The Dog & Partridge Inn in Flouch, said keeping the westbound carriageway of the A628 Woodhead Pass shut makes "no sense", as the nearby car fire that originally triggered the closure has been extinguished, though a much larger moorland fire still burns some 10 miles away near Glossop.
The A628 was closed on Thursday after a car crash sparked a moorland blaze, and remains partially shut, with National Highways saying it expects the closure to last until at least Monday 27 July while diversions are reviewed daily. About 65 firefighters from ten services are tackling the separate, larger Tintwistle Moor fire, which could burn for another week. National Highways said it is installing signage confirming the pub is open and adjusting the closure to allow safe access in both directions, while Marsh, who says he is losing "thousands of pounds a week", is also pressing the agency to avoid scheduling planned bridge repair works during the pub's busiest August weekends.
In short
- Wildfire road closure near Sheffield is hitting pub trade
- Landlord fears job losses despite nearby car fire being out
- Larger Tintwistle Moor fire, fought by 65 firefighters, could burn a week
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The pub landlord's argument holds that the closure of the A628 Woodhead Pass is overly broad given that the immediate car fire has been extinguished and the larger Tintwistle Moor fire lies some considerable distance away. He is suffering substantial economic losses—thousands of pounds weekly and potential staff redundancies—which raises legitimate questions about whether the closure's scope and duration are proportionate to the actual ongoing threat. The fact that National Highways is already making adjustments suggests there may be room for a more nuanced approach that balances emergency response with the livelihoods of affected local businesses.
The case against
National Highways must prioritise public safety over individual commercial interests during an active wildfire emergency. Even though the initial car fire is extinguished, the Tintwistle Moor fire still poses genuine hazards including potential ember attack, air quality risks, and unpredictable fire behaviour that could threaten the road corridor. Keeping emergency routes clear is essential for firefighting operations and evacuation if required, and maintaining the closure until the larger fire is fully controlled is a reasonable and responsible precautionary measure to protect the public, however burdensome this may be for local businesses.
Explained simply
A pub in South Yorkshire is facing significant financial loss due to a road closure on the A628 Woodhead Pass near Sheffield. Steve Marsh, who runs The Dog & Partridge Inn in Flouch, says the shutdown has cut off passing trade that is vital to his business and may force him to lay off staff.
The road was closed on Thursday after a car crash sparked a fire on nearby moorland. Although that initial car fire has been extinguished, the closure remains in place because a much larger wildfire continues burning on Tintwistle Moor, some 10 miles away near Glossop. Around 65 firefighters from ten different services are tackling this larger blaze, which is expected to continue for another week.
National Highways expects to maintain the partial closure until at least 27 July whilst managing the fire risk and reviewing diversion routes. Marsh is also concerned about planned bridge repair works being scheduled during his pub's busiest August weekends, adding to the pressures facing the business.