News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Sheffield Our Cow Molly ice cream is so popular they’ve had to move a footpath on the farm
Sheffield dairy farm and ice-cream maker Our Cow Molly has moved a public footpath running through its site because growing visitor numbers made the previous route impractical. The change reflects the business’s popularity while seeking to keep the farm operating safely and preserve public access for walkers.
Our Cow Molly is based at Cliffe House Farm in Dungworth, on Sheffield’s western edge, and makes ice cream using milk and cream from its own herd. The farm has produced ice cream since 2007 and is a popular destination for visitors, cyclists and walkers; the diverted path provides an alternative route around the site.
In short
- Popularity prompted Our Cow Molly to reroute a farm footpath.
- The change aims to balance visitor safety and walking access.
- The Dungworth farm makes ice cream from its own dairy.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The farm's decision to relocate the footpath reflects a responsible approach to managing genuine safety challenges created by their commercial success. As visitor numbers have grown substantially, maintaining the original route would have compromised both farm operations and visitor experience, creating congestion and potential hazards. By providing a carefully planned alternative that preserves public access whilst allowing the business to function safely and sustainably, the farm has found a reasonable compromise that serves both operational needs and the public interest in continued countryside access.
The case against
Public footpaths represent important legal rights that deserve careful protection, and allowing popular private businesses to simply redirect established routes sets a problematic precedent. The farm's commercial success, whilst welcome, should not necessitate altering the public's legal entitlements; rather, the farm should manage its operations around existing rights of way. Once public paths become subject to business convenience, the principle of public access becomes negotiable, and future businesses may follow suit to progressively restrict authentic routes, ultimately undermining the purpose of public rights of way protection.
Explained simply
Our Cow Molly is a dairy farm and ice cream business at Cliffe House Farm on Sheffield's western edge, which makes ice cream from milk and cream produced by its own herd. The farm has been making ice cream for nearly two decades and has become a popular destination for visitors, walkers and cyclists.
The farm's growing popularity has created practical challenges for operations, so the operators have diverted a public footpath that previously ran through the site. The new route runs around the farm instead, allowing walkers to continue using the area whilst enabling the business to operate more safely and efficiently.