Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
What if Gyms stopped giving free PokéCoins? Pokémon Go survey has players concerned over the future of Gyms
A Niantic Labs survey has prompted concern among Pokémon Go players after asking how they would react if Gyms no longer awarded PokéCoins. The question does not confirm a planned change, but players fear losing one of the game’s main free-currency sources could reduce Gym participation or cause some to stop playing.
Players can currently earn up to 50 PokéCoins a day when a Pokémon is removed from a Gym, at one coin per 10 minutes of defence; earning the maximum requires eight hours and 20 minutes. The system is harder to use in rural areas with fewer Gyms, leading some players to call for a rework or alternative daily coin-earning methods. PokéCoins pay for items such as Raid Passes, avatar cosmetics and gameplay boosts, and are the only affordable source of currency for many regular players.
In short
- A survey question has raised fears over free PokéCoins from Gyms.
- Players can currently earn up to 50 PokéCoins daily.
- Rural players want fairer alternative ways to earn coins.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Niantic requires sustainable revenue to maintain servers, development, and ongoing support for Pokémon Go. Free PokéCoins from Gyms directly reduce the incentive for players to spend money, competing with the company's monetisation strategy. Other successful free-to-play games maintain profitability through careful calibration of free versus premium currency, and adjusting this revenue stream would help ensure the game can continue receiving updates and improvements for years to come.
The case against
Free-to-play games require some accessible free currency to maintain fairness and community goodwill. PokéCoins are the only affordable way many regular players can access essential items like Raid Passes; removing this source would create significant pay-to-win imbalance, particularly harming rural players who already struggle with fewer Gyms. A thriving, inclusive player base—including those unwilling or unable to spend—generates the network effects and engagement that sustain long-term revenue; alienating free players through excessive monetisation would ultimately harm the game's viability.
Explained simply
Pokémon Go is a mobile game where players catch virtual creatures in the real world using their phones. In the game, Gyms are specific locations where players can place their Pokémon to defend them.
When a player's Pokémon is defeated and removed from a Gym, that player earns PokéCoins, the game's main currency used to buy raid passes, cosmetics and other items. For most regular players, this is the primary way to obtain these coins without spending real money.
The Gym-based reward system is especially valuable in rural areas where fewer Gyms exist, making it harder for players otherwise to access paid features. Changes to how Gyms reward players could discourage people from using them, potentially affecting how engaged players remain with the game.