Kagi Brings Back Old-School Search, One Human-Made Website at a Time
Kagi is expanding beyond its paid, privacy-focused search engine with a “Small Web” project designed to surface websites created and curated by people. The initiative responds to concerns that search and online publishing are increasingly shaped by advertising, algorithms and AI-generated material, and aims to recreate some of the discovery associated with the early web.
Kagi’s search service offers 100 free trial searches, then costs from $5 a month for 300 searches or $10 a month for unlimited searches and additional AI-assistant use. It says subscribers pay directly rather than through personal data or advertising, while its search results emphasise its own web and news indexes, non-commercial sites, and the absence of sponsored links; the Small Web feature lets users browse selected sites at random, save favourites and search for particular content.
In short
- Kagi is promoting a curated, human-made “Small Web”.
- Its paid search aims to avoid adverts and data-driven targeting.
- Prices start at $5 monthly after a 100-search trial.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Proponents argue that contemporary search has been corrupted by profit motives, leaving users drowning in spam, sponsored results and AI-generated content rather than genuine human expertise. They contend that privacy-respecting, human-curated search represents a necessary corrective—one that treats users as customers deserving transparency rather than products to be monetised. By charging directly, Kagi aligns incentives with user satisfaction rather than advertising revenue, whilst its Small Web initiative restores the serendipitous discovery and authentic human voice that made early internet research rewarding and trustworthy.
The case against
Critics argue that free, algorithmically-driven search has demonstrably served billions by making information vastly more accessible and searchable than manual curation ever could. They suggest Kagi's model prioritises ideological preference and profit over genuine utility, offering a premium service primarily benefiting wealthy nations whilst leaving most of humanity reliant on advertising-supported alternatives. The nostalgia for old-web discovery overlooks real improvements in accessibility and inclusivity; moreover, they contend that human curation introduces its own biases and scales poorly compared to algorithmic approaches that can adapt to individual needs.
Explained simply
Kagi is a search engine where users pay between £5 and £10 per month to use its service. Rather than making money from advertising or selling personal data, it charges directly and provides search results that emphasise independent websites and news sources without sponsored links.
The company has launched a "Small Web" project that highlights websites made and run by individual people or small communities. Rather than using automated systems to decide what to show users, it presents content that has been manually chosen, allowing people to browse through these sites randomly, save their favourites, and search within them.
This responds to growing concern that modern search engines and online publishing have become dominated by advertising, automated systems and computer-generated material. Many people believe the early internet offered more scope for discovery and human creativity, and the project aims to restore some of that experience.