News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Church’s £250,000 repair bill forces closure
The Parish Church of St John the Baptist in Dodworth, near Barnsley, is set to close permanently after being hit with a repair bill exceeding £250,000. The 200-year-old Grade II listed building needs a full Welsh slate roof replacement, structural timber and beam repairs, and work to fix water ingress, costs the diocese has said are beyond its resources. The closure highlights the growing financial pressure facing historic churches across the UK as maintenance costs for ageing, listed buildings continue to rise.
Canon Keith Farrow said the estimated cost had initially seemed to be around £40,000 before growing into a much larger restoration project, prompting the diocese to begin formal closure proceedings this week. The church had already closed temporarily in May for repairs and structural surveys. Services are now being held at the Methodist Church on Green Road, and a public consultation on the closure is scheduled for 12 August at 19:00 BST.
In short
- Dodworth church faces permanent closure over £250,000 repair costs
- Roof, timber and water damage repairs deemed unaffordable by diocese
- Public consultation on closure set for 12 August
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Historic churches represent irreplaceable cultural and architectural heritage with value beyond their role as places of worship. Grade II listed buildings are protected precisely because they have significant historical and artistic merit; when institutions lack resources for necessary repairs, this is a case for greater public and charitable support for heritage preservation as a collective responsibility. Society stands to lose permanent cultural assets if we allow these buildings to close simply because individual organisations cannot fund expensive restoration work.
The case against
Religious institutions must manage their property portfolios responsibly, and if a church cannot sustain necessary repairs, this suggests the property is no longer viable under that institution's stewardship. Directing public funds to subsidise maintenance of privately-owned religious buildings, particularly when public services face severe funding pressures, requires careful justification. Heritage preservation matters, but should be addressed through transparent, equitable public programmes rather than by default supporting specific institutions' choices to retain unprofitable properties.
Explained simply
The Parish Church of St John the Baptist in Dodworth, near Barnsley, is a 200-year-old stone building with Grade II listed status. Essential repairs needed to the building have been estimated to cost more than £250,000. The work includes replacing the slate roof, repairing structural damage to timber and beams, and stopping water leaks through the building.
The Diocese, which is responsible for the church's upkeep, says it cannot afford to pay for these repairs. Initial estimates for the work were only about £40,000, but the true cost became clear during structural surveys and increased much further. Worshippers are now using the nearby Methodist Church for their regular Sunday services.
This closure reflects a growing problem affecting historic churches throughout the UK. Many old and listed buildings require increasingly expensive maintenance work, yet the organisations running them struggle to find enough money for repairs. The closure raises questions about how hundreds of ageing religious buildings with similar financial pressures will be maintained in future.