News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
EMR boss to leave role amid ongoing train problems
The managing director of East Midlands Railway, Will Rogers, is stepping down from his role on Monday amid ongoing problems with the operator's new train fleet. Company operator Transport UK Group confirmed his departure, which follows persistent reliability and maintenance issues with the new Aurora (Class 810) trains built by Hitachi Rail, issues that have forced EMR to cut back services and cancel a number of Intercity routes to and from London St Pancras.
Rogers joined EMR in January 2020 and led the business through the Covid pandemic, the retirement of its high-speed trains, a fleet refurbishment programme and the introduction of the Aurora trains, as well as the launch of EMR Connect between Corby and London St Pancras. He also oversaw the company's response to the fatal train crash near Bedford on 19 June. Experts have pointed to hot weather, a shortage of stock and "teething problems" with the new trains as factors behind EMR's difficulties. Neil Grabham, currently managing director of Merseyrail and a former EMR customer services director, will take over as interim managing director.
In short
- EMR boss Will Rogers to leave role on Monday
- Departure follows reliability issues with new Aurora trains
- Neil Grabham of Merseyrail named interim managing director
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A managing director bears ultimate responsibility for their company's operational performance and customer experience. Rogers oversaw the introduction of the Aurora trains and presided over a period of significant service disruptions, forcing route cancellations and service cuts that directly harmed passengers. Regardless of contributing external factors, leadership at this level must take responsibility for navigating crises effectively, and his departure signals that the company takes these operational failures seriously and seeks fresh direction.
The case against
The problems afflicting EMR appear largely structural rather than attributable to management failure: the Aurora trains have manufacturing defects traceable to Hitachi Rail, supply chain shortages affect the rail sector broadly, and weather-related issues are external. Rogers demonstrated capable leadership through Covid, fleet transitions and other major challenges since January 2020. Removing an experienced leader during technical crises rather than addressing root causes in manufacturing and systemic supply may constitute scapegoating and could further destabilise the company's recovery.
Explained simply
East Midlands Railway is a train operator providing passenger services in the East Midlands region and running intercity routes to London. The company has encountered persistent problems with its new Aurora (Class 810) train fleet, built by Hitachi Rail, which has experienced significant reliability and maintenance issues since entering service.
These difficulties have led EMR to reduce services and cancel intercity routes to London St Pancras, affecting passengers and disrupting the company's operations. Experts have cited hot weather, a shortage of spare trains, and teething problems with the new fleet as contributing factors. The issues have been serious enough to create substantial operational challenges for the operator.