Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Children left sidelined at school up to twice as likely to become jobless and not be in education or training when turning 18, study finds
A study has found that children who are sidelined or excluded at school are up to twice as likely to end up out of work, education or training (NEET) by the age of 18. The research highlights a strong link between negative school experiences, such as exclusion or feeling marginalised, and poor long-term outcomes for young people entering adulthood, adding urgency to concerns about Britain's youth jobs crisis.
The findings come as Prime Minister Andy Burnham has pledged to tackle the rising number of NEETs, though he has stopped short of setting a firm deadline for reducing the figure. As part of this shift, Burnham is moving away from the Blair-era push for school leavers to go to university, signalling a change in approach towards vocational and alternative pathways for young people who struggle within mainstream education.
In short
- Sidelined pupils twice as likely to become NEET by 18, study finds
- Burnham vows to tackle youth jobs crisis, no deadline set
- Government shifts away from Blair's university-for-all school leaver drive
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The research shows that school exclusion and sidelining are strongly linked to poor outcomes, so the priority must be reducing exclusion itself. Many children are excluded due to inadequate school resources for mental health, special needs, and disadvantaged students—not because they cannot succeed. Rather than accepting this exclusion and developing alternatives, we should invest in more inclusive mainstream education with proper staffing and targeted support.
The case against
The research reveals that significant numbers of young people are excluded or sidelined in mainstream schools, suggesting we need to develop genuinely valued alternative pathways rather than insist one model fits all. Young people have diverse needs and abilities; for many, vocational or technical education is better suited than academics and offers superior employment prospects. We should invest in high-quality alternative education with respected qualifications and industry links, giving students real choices rather than forcing them into unsuitable mainstream systems.
Explained simply
NEET stands for "Not in Education, Employment or Training". It refers to young people who have left school but are not working, studying, or in any form of training.
School exclusion and being sidelined describe situations where children are removed from mainstream education or feel marginalised within it. These experiences can interrupt education and create challenges as young people prepare for their transition to adulthood.
Britain has faced persistent concerns about youth employment, with significant numbers of young people struggling to secure work or training opportunities after leaving school. This has become a key policy issue because it affects long-term life prospects, and because it raises questions about how to support young people who do not thrive in traditional school settings.