Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Report shows 34% of physical PS5 games and 50% of Xbox Series X games do not work fully without a download first
A report has found that a significant share of physical PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X games cannot be used fully straight from the disc, instead requiring an initial download. This matters because it limits the long-term usefulness of boxed games for players without reliable internet access and raises preservation concerns.
According to the report, 34% of physical PS5 releases and 50% of Xbox Series X releases need downloads before they work completely. The findings suggest that owning a disc does not always guarantee a self-contained, playable copy of a modern game.
In short
- Many physical current-generation games still require downloads.
- Half of Xbox Series X titles reportedly need one.
- The trend raises access and preservation concerns.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Physical discs are often marketed and valued as copies people can own, lend, resell and keep playable over time. If a game needs a download to work fully, that weakens those benefits and can exclude players with unreliable internet; it also raises preservation concerns if updates or required files later become unavailable.
The case against
Modern games are complex products that may need substantial updates to fix bugs, improve performance or add content after release. Requiring a download can help developers deliver a better experience and meet players’ expectations, while a disc still offers a useful installation source and a degree of ownership even when it is not a complete, permanently self-contained copy.
Explained simply
PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X games are sold both as downloads and on physical discs. A disc can contain a game’s data, but some games also need files downloaded from the internet before all their features work.
This matters because a disc may not be enough to play a game fully if a player has no reliable internet connection. It also raises questions about how well physical games can be preserved for future play, as online services and downloads may not always remain available.