News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Mayors welcome new powers from Burnham
Three Yorkshire mayors have welcomed plans by Prime Minister Andy Burnham to give English city-region mayors a share of income tax revenue and wider control over transport, housebuilding and youth employment. The proposals are intended to shift power from Westminster and provide local leaders with more stable, long-term funding, although questions remain over whether they will substantially reduce regional inequality.
South Yorkshire’s Oliver Coppard said the change would allow longer-term investment and borrowing without raising local income-tax rates, while West Yorkshire’s Tracy Brabin and York and North Yorkshire’s David Skaith highlighted potential improvements to skills, homes and public transport. Mayors currently rely mainly on central government grants; they are expected to retain some business-rates revenue from April 2027 and receive a portion of income-tax revenue from April 2028. Conservative shadow chancellor Sir Mel Stride criticised the announcement as lacking detail and offering no new money.
In short
- Yorkshire mayors welcome greater financial and policy control.
- Income-tax revenue sharing is planned from April 2028.
- Critics say the proposals contain little detail or new funding.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of mayoral devolution can genuinely argue that decisions about transport, housing and employment are best made by regional leaders who understand local conditions and priorities. Shifting from Westminster dependence to stable, tax-based revenue provides the long-term certainty needed for meaningful infrastructure investment, whilst accountability remains grounded in local communities. This represents a meaningful redistribution of democratic power closer to those affected by these decisions.
The case against
Sceptics can reasonably contend that the scheme's acknowledged lack of detail raises serious questions about its viability and whether it genuinely transfers additional resources or merely reshuffles existing funding. There are legitimate concerns that income-tax-based devolution may widen regional disparities, as economically stronger areas will generate more revenue whilst poorer regions lack the tax base to fund comparable development. Without fuller information, it remains unclear whether this actually reduces inequality as intended.
Explained simply
English mayors lead elected authorities that cover a city and its surrounding towns and areas. They already make some decisions on local services, but much of their funding comes from grants set by the UK government in Westminster.
South Yorkshire mayor Oliver Coppard, West Yorkshire mayor Tracy Brabin and York and North Yorkshire mayor David Skaith say steadier funding and more control could help them plan transport, housing and jobs programmes over several years. The proposals would give mayors a share of national income-tax revenue, without changing local tax rates, and broader powers in some areas.
The change matters because English regions differ in jobs, transport and housing, and local leaders say they need more say in tackling those gaps. It remains uncertain how much the new arrangements would reduce regional inequality, while critics say the funding plans lack detail.