Two Indiana teenagers jailed for more than 200 YEARS over woman’s brutal murder
Two Indiana teenagers, Jo’Majze Larry and Rashawn Samuels, have been sentenced to a combined 225 years in prison for their roles in the killing of 26-year-old Dayla Swain outside a bar in Anderson in February 2025. The case is significant because Larry, who was 14 at the time of the shooting, received a 100-year sentence, while Samuels, 19, received 125 years after both were convicted of murder-related offences.
Prosecutors said the attack was intended to silence Swain’s cousin, a prospective witness in an unrelated murder case. Larry was convicted of murder, attempted murder, conspiracy and gang-related offences, while Samuels was convicted of aiding murder and related charges; both sentences included substantial enhancements for criminal organisation activity.
In short
- Two teenagers received combined prison terms of 225 years.
- The victim, Dayla Swain, was killed outside an Anderson bar.
- Prosecutors said the shooting aimed to silence a witness.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
These sentences appropriately reflect the severity of premeditated murder and conspiracy to silence a witness—deliberate acts that destroyed a young woman's life. Justice requires that serious crimes face serious consequences; reduced sentences would undervalue the victim and fail to protect communities from organised violence. Whilst age is a sentencing consideration, it cannot negate culpability for orchestrating a killing. The enhancement for gang-related activity recognises the broader harm of criminal organisation.
The case against
Sentencing a 14-year-old to a century in prison raises fundamental questions about proportionality and the purpose of criminal justice. Adolescent brains continue developing into the mid-20s, affecting judgment and impulse control—well-established neuroscience that argues against permanent incapacitation based on childhood actions. Such sentences eliminate any prospect of rehabilitation and raise serious concerns about human dignity. Progressive justice systems recognise that holding young people accountable need not require abandoning the possibility that they can eventually change and reintegrate into society.
Explained simply
Anderson is a city in Indiana, in the United States. Dayla Swain was 26 when she was killed outside a bar there in February 2025; two people were later convicted of offences connected to her death.
Prosecutors said the shooting was meant to stop Swain’s cousin from giving evidence in a separate murder case. The convictions included murder-related and gang-related offences, and the sentences differed according to each defendant’s role and age.