World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Knickers in a twist: why M&S selling crotchless panties isn’t as outrageous as it seems
Marks & Spencer has faced online criticism for selling Ann Summers crotchless knickers, but the article argues the move is a relatively unsurprising extension of its broader lingerie range. It reflects M&S’s effort to offer more choice, attract younger shoppers and expand its online third-party brand strategy, rather than a fundamental break with its long history in underwear retail.
Ann Summers products, including bras and chemises, now sit alongside brands such as Pour Moi and Calvin Klein on the M&S website. M&S says under-30s accounted for a third of its underwear sales in 2024, twice the proportion in 2023, while the retailer has sold underwear since the 1920s and has repeatedly adapted to changing fashions, from full briefs to thongs, period pants and stoma-friendly designs. A retail consultant also suggests the controversy may generate attention that encourages customers to browse and make other underwear purchases.
In short
- M&S’s Ann Summers partnership broadens its lingerie offer.
- The retailer is seeking to retain younger underwear shoppers.
- Underwear styles have long evolved with changing fashions.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
M&S's decision represents sensible retail evolution. The company has routinely adapted its lingerie range—from briefs to thongs to period pants—and stocking Ann Summers alongside Calvin Klein and Pour Moi simply continues this pattern whilst serving younger shoppers more effectively. This is straightforward third-party marketplace strategy, not boundary-crossing.
The case against
There is a meaningful distinction between expanding lingerie variety and stocking products explicitly designed for adult entertainment. M&S carries distinctive brand heritage as a mainstream family retailer, and expanding into categories that blur this positioning risks eroding customer expectations and brand values. Not every commercial opportunity strengthens a brand in the long term.
Explained simply
Marks & Spencer has sold underwear since the 1920s, adapting its range as fashions and customer needs have changed. Its lingerie offer now includes different styles and specialist designs, as well as products from other labels sold through its website.
Ann Summers is a British lingerie retailer known for more revealing underwear. M&S also sells labels such as Pour Moi and Calvin Klein, as it broadens its choice and seeks to appeal to younger shoppers.
The issue sits within a wider change in how retailers compete: M&S is combining its own products with other brands online. Its underwear sales to under-30s have grown, making the range part of its effort to attract a broader mix of customers.
Americas Art Business Culture World