Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Shittu ‘robbed’ – are AI boxing judges the answer?
England's Dimeji Shittu was left with a Commonwealth Games silver medal rather than gold after a controversial points defeat by India's Ankush Panghal in the boxing final in Glasgow, prompting pundits to call the decision a "robbery". The result has reignited long-standing debate about subjectivity in boxing judging, with calls growing for artificial intelligence to be introduced to make scoring more transparent and consistent.
Shittu, 24, won the opening round on all five judges' scorecards but was then deducted a point in both the second and third rounds for dipping his head, swinging the contest despite appearing to land more punches. Remarkably, four of the five judges still awarded the final round to Ankush, meaning Shittu would have lost even without the penalties. Former champion Richie Woodhall and 2022 gold medallist Delicious Orie both condemned the officiating on TNT Sports, with Orie suggesting AI judging could help; the sport's governing body, World Boxing, led by Gennadiy Golovkin, has begun exploring the technology, though no changes are imminent. Shittu himself declined to blame officials, saying "whatever the referee says goes".
In short
- Dimeji Shittu lost a controversial boxing final on points to India's Ankush Panghal
- Pundits called the judging "robbery"; penalties and scoring were heavily criticised
- Calls growing for AI-assisted judging, though World Boxing has no imminent plans
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Proponents of AI judging argue that human subjectivity has caused demonstrable injustices in boxing, as exemplified by the Shittu case, where penalties and questionable scorecards determined the outcome. AI systems can objectively measure punch accuracy, frequency, and impact without bias, providing consistent standards across all bouts and eliminating the influence of hometown bias, fighter reputation, or judgemental inconsistency. This would make the sport fairer and more transparent, restoring credibility to contested decisions.
The case against
Critics contend that boxing is fundamentally an art requiring human evaluation of ring generalship, technical proficiency, and effective aggression—elements that cannot be reduced to punch statistics alone. AI systems would need extensive validation and could embed their own biases depending on how they are programmed and trained. Implementation also raises practical concerns about cost, employment displacement, and whether over-codification might diminish the sport's interpretive dimension that makes it compelling to experienced observers.
Explained simply
Boxing bouts are scored by ringside judges, who assess each round and award points for factors such as clean punches, effective attack and defence. A referee oversees the contest and can deduct points for rule breaches; those deductions can affect the final result.
The Commonwealth Games bring together teams from across the Commonwealth, with boxers competing for their countries. Dimeji Shittu represented England, while Ankush Panghal represented India, and their final has drawn attention to how much judges’ assessments can shape a close bout.
World Boxing, the sport’s governing body, is led by former champion Gennadiy Golovkin and has begun exploring whether artificial intelligence could assist scoring. The debate matters because any system used to judge bouts could affect athletes’ results and how spectators understand decisions.
AI Art Culture Sport Technology UK World