Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Evie Was Created by Our Talented Artists’: Stellar Blade Dev Responds to ‘AI Slop’ Accusations
Shift Up boss Hyung-Tae Kim has defended the studio's AI-generated music video for Stellar Blade: Blood Rain after fans accused the company of releasing "AI slop." Responding to a follower who questioned why the studio wasn't relying on its "talented artists," Kim argued that the video's star, new protagonist Evie, was hand-crafted by artists and modellers over more than a year, and that the generative AI was only used to render her movements rather than create her from scratch. The row matters because Shift Up, founded by illustrators, has built its reputation on strong character art, and fans feel that reputation is being undermined by visibly AI-assisted content.
The music video, for the song "Wanna Be in Love," depicts Evie singing in Blood Rain's China-inspired city setting, but was criticised for uncanny facial expressions and visual errors typical of generative AI, having been produced through Shift Up's AI Labs division. This follows a similarly AI-heavy reveal trailer for the game, and even the studio's own fan account publicly voiced disappointment. Push Square's editor notes that Kim's explanation may not satisfy critics, since the generative tool likely draws on vast uncredited external data even if Evie's original design is Shift Up's own work, and suggests Blood Rain is likely to feature further AI-generated content ahead of release.
In short
- Shift Up defends AI music video for Stellar Blade: Blood Rain amid backlash.
- Boss says character Evie was hand-designed; AI only renders her movement.
- Critics say generative AI still relies on uncredited external training data.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The character Evie was created entirely by Shift Up's artists over more than a year of dedicated work. The studio employed generative AI solely for animating her movements—a narrow technical application comparable to motion-capture or rendering software already standard in modern animation pipelines. Using emerging technology to automate specific production tasks is a reasonable way to allocate limited artistic resources toward character design and creative direction.
The case against
Shift Up has built its reputation on exceptional hand-crafted character art, making the visible quality problems in AI-animated content a betrayal of that identity and fan expectations. Beyond aesthetics, generative AI training on vast uncredited external data raises genuine ethical concerns about appropriation; the studio's choice to employ such tools, even for limited animation work, feels inconsistent with authentic artistic integrity and respect for creative workers.
Explained simply
Shift Up is a South Korean game studio founded by artists and known for games with highly detailed character designs. Stellar Blade is one of its games; Blood Rain is a related project set in a city inspired by China. Evie is the new protagonist, or central character, in Blood Rain.
Generative AI is software that can produce images or movement from patterns learned from existing data. In this case, Shift Up says its artists designed and modelled Evie, while AI was used to animate her for a music video. Some fans object to the visible use of AI, including because its training data may include work used without artists’ permission.
The debate matters because it touches on how studios use AI and how that affects artists’ work and audiences’ trust. It is especially relevant for Shift Up, whose reputation is closely tied to its character art.
AI Art Culture Entertainment Music Technology