Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Ice Cream Man fails to deliver genuine scares, critic warns
Developed over time first seen 3 months ago
Variety's chief film critic Owen Gleiberman has panned Eli Roth's new horror film "Ice Cream Man," calling it a shamelessly derivative and ham-handed piece of shock cinema rather than genuine horror. The review argues that while Roth has previously delivered effective transgressive horror in films such as "Hostel: Part II" and "Thanksgiving," this latest effort borrows heavily from superior works including "Village of the Damned" and "Halloween" without matching their craft, resulting in a one-note splatter movie that is more ludicrous than frightening.
The plot centres on a sinister ice-cream vendor (Ari Millen) in the town of Bayleen Bay who hands out demonically possessed cones to local children, turning them into a murderous zombie cult that slaughters teachers and parents using household tools such as hacksaws, baseball bats, electric sanders and garden shears. Roth himself appears in the film as the doomed geek father of the young hero, and the review dismisses the whole enterprise as bare-bones, garish "kiddie zombie splatter schlock" despite its shock-value ambitions.
- Sources
- 2
- Outlets
- 2
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 0 · 0
In short
- Variety critic pans Eli Roth's "Ice Cream Man" as derivative splatter schlock
- Demonic ice cream turns children into a killer zombie cult
- Reviewer says film borrows from better films like "Halloween"
How this story developed
- 3 months ago The critique was reframed to stress the film's crude "analog suburban" style of bloodshed, with the household weapons described more broadly as everyday objects rather than an itemised list, and Roth's onscreen father figure recast simply as doomed rather than specifically geeky, underscoring the reviewer's view that the violence itself is the film's defining, if unimaginative, gimmick.
- 3 months ago Variety chief critic Owen Gleiberman published a scathing review of Eli Roth's "Ice Cream Man," branding it derivative, gimmicky shock cinema that apes superior films such as "Village of the Damned" and "Halloween" without their skill, following a plot in which a sinister vendor (Ari Millen) in Bayleen Bay turns local children into a tool-wielding zombie cult that kills adults, with Roth himself cast as the young hero's ill-fated geeky father.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Not all horror aspires to psychological complexity or innovation. Ice Cream Man is deliberately absurdist splatter entertainment—the premise of a demon ice cream man turning children into zombie murderers is intentionally preposterous. Within the exploitation and B-movie tradition, this kind of unhinged, practical-effects-driven gore has genuine entertainment value as transgressive cinema that embraces rather than denies its own ridiculousness. A film can succeed on its own terms as campy, shock-value fun without needing to match the craft of films like Halloween.
The case against
Derivative imitation without craft or added vision is a legitimate artistic failing, whatever the intended tone. The film borrows directly from superior works without justifying these references or developing its own distinctive voice. If a feature-length film's primary appeal is shock value alone—as the 'one-note' criticism suggests—that provides insufficient substance for sustained engagement. Roth's earlier work demonstrates he can merge transgression with skill, making this purely shock-based approach a particular disappointment rather than a legitimate stylistic choice.
Explained simply
Eli Roth is an American filmmaker known for graphic, provocative horror films such as "Hostel" and its sequels, as well as more recent titles like "Thanksgiving". He has built a reputation over two decades as one of horror's more divisive directors, often courting controversy with extreme on-screen violence rather than subtler, atmospheric scares.
"Ice Cream Man" is his latest release, a horror film in which a mysterious ice-cream seller in a small town corrupts local children with his products, turning them into a violent mob that attacks the adults around them. The premise draws on a long tradition of horror stories about children turned sinister or possessed, a genre with well-known predecessors going back decades.
Film reviews from major outlets such as Variety carry weight in shaping how a new release is received by audiences and the wider industry, particularly for a director like Roth whose films tend to attract strong opinions. Critical reception can influence box office performance, streaming visibility and a filmmaker's standing for future projects.
Coverage · 2 sources
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Variety as “‘Ice Cream Man’ Review: Eli Roth’s Children-of-the-Damned Splatter Movie Is No Treat”.