Toone grateful to Skinner after his Man Utd departure
Manchester United midfielder Ella Toone has said she will always be "grateful" to former manager Marc Skinner, who left the club by mutual consent this week after five years in charge, particularly for the support he gave her following the death of her father in September 2024. Skinner's departure comes at an uncertain time for United's women's team, with the club losing several first-team players this summer, doubts over ownership investment, and pressure to appoint a new manager before the WSL season begins.
Skinner led United to their first Champions League knockout stage and their maiden major trophy, the 2024 Women's FA Cup, but faced fan criticism and departs after a fourth-place WSL finish that cost the club European qualification. Toone and captain Maya Le Tissier said they were not consulted on his replacement but expect an appointment soon, with United reportedly favouring a coach who develops young talent amid reduced summer spending and the exits of players including Melvine Malard and Gabby George.
- Marc Skinner leaves Man Utd Women by mutual consent after five years
- Toone thanked him for support after her father's death
- Club expects to name a new manager soon before WSL season
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Marc Skinner delivered historic achievement to Manchester United, taking the club to its first Champions League knockout stage and winning its maiden major trophy in the FA Cup. Beyond these accomplishments, he demonstrated genuine leadership by providing meaningful personal support to players during their most difficult moments. His tenure transformed the club's standing and competitive position, justifying the gratitude that figures like Toone express.
The case against
A manager's legacy must ultimately rest upon sustained results and outcomes, and Skinner's final season saw Manchester United finish fourth and miss European qualification. The subsequent departure of key players and current uncertainty suggest his tenure ended in disappointment rather than success. Whilst early achievements were noteworthy, they were not sustained, and the club now faces considerable rebuilding, indicating his tenure ultimately underperformed expectations for a club of United's stature.