Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story’ Sets Netflix Release Date, Unveils First-Look Photos
Netflix has announced a September 17 release for 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story,' the latest addition to Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan's anthology series. Starring Ella Beatty in the title role, the production features an ensemble cast including Vicky Krieps, Rebecca Hall, and Charlie Hunnam. The series marks the first instalment in the franchise to centre on a female protagonist, expanding the anthology's scope beyond its previous character studies.
The show reframes the historical Lizzie Borden case as a psychological narrative about constraint and rebellion within a privileged New England family. Rather than dwelling solely on the crimes themselves, the story emphasises how the central character forges her own identity and legacy whilst rejecting the limitations imposed by family and society. This approach aligns with the Monster series' pattern of presenting controversial historical figures through a modern interpretive lens, prioritising character motivation and agency.
In short
- Netflix releases 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' on September 17 as part of Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan's ongoing anthology series
- Ella Beatty leads the cast in the anthology's first female-centred story, joined by Vicky Krieps, Rebecca Hall, and Charlie Hunnam
- The series reimagines the historical figure as an agent of her own narrative, emphasising psychological motivation over crime-focused storytelling
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Dramatising historical figures through a psychological lens that explores motivation and social constraint serves legitimate artistic and educational purposes. By examining how personal agency and societal limitations shaped Lizzie Borden's life, the series can illuminate complex historical truths that pure factual recitation might miss. Such character-driven narratives invite audiences to grapple with nuance and complexity, offering valuable insight into how circumstances, expectations, and human nature intersect during pivotal moments in history.
The case against
Reframing a brutal historical crime around the psychological experience of the accused raises ethical concerns about whom a narrative centres on and how. By emphasising constraint, rebellion, and agency for someone credibly suspected of murdering two people, the series risks inviting sympathy or justification for violent acts whilst potentially marginalising the victims' experiences. Dramatists working with real crimes carry responsibility to historical truth and to those who suffered, not merely to character exploration or entertainment value.
Explained simply
Lizzie Borden was a woman from a wealthy Massachusetts family who became notorious in the 1890s after her father and stepmother were killed at home. She was tried and acquitted, but public suspicion and debate about the case continued.
Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan’s Monster is an anthology series, with each instalment telling a different story about a notorious person or case. This instalment focuses on Borden’s family life and how social expectations shaped her, offering a dramatised interpretation rather than a documentary account.