Telegram CEO says an extortionist planted CSAM in a chat to get it pulled from the App Store
Telegram CEO Pavel Durov has said the app was briefly removed from Apple's App Store after an extortionist planted child sexual abuse material (CSAM) in a public chat, aiming to trigger a takedown. Durov said Apple pulled Telegram on Monday night without first contacting the company, warning that this sets a troubling precedent that could see any user-generated content app removed without warning. Telegram was restored within hours, but Durov used the incident to highlight what he describes as a broader extortion tactic targeting apps that host public communities.
According to Durov, the attacker evaded Telegram's moderation by editing an old message in an active group chat to insert AI-modified illegal content, effectively hiding it from group members who might otherwise have reported it. He said such "takedown extortionists" use automated accounts to plant illegal material and then report it directly to Apple, pressuring group owners who refuse to pay ransoms. Durov maintains that illegal content is not a systemic problem on Telegram given its moderation tools, and noted the case comes amid separate legal troubles, including a Russian arrest warrant and his 2024 arrest in France. Apple had not responded to a request for comment at the time of publication.
In short
- Telegram briefly pulled from App Store over planted CSAM content
- Durov blames extortionist who hid illegal content via edited message
- Apple removed app before contacting Telegram; service restored hours later
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Child sexual abuse material represents an imminent, ongoing harm that demands immediate action; delay allows continued victimisation and gives bad actors time to obscure evidence. Apple cannot permit verification of extortion claims to supersede child protection, especially when the illegal content itself is confirmed and harmful. All platforms hosting user-generated content bear responsibility for that content, and swift enforcement of accountability is essential. The app's swift restoration demonstrates that Apple acted proportionately and temporarily to address an acute harm.
The case against
Removing an app used by hundreds of millions without warning or contact sets a dangerous precedent that invites extortion and manipulation. Durov's account of the attack—exploiting message-editing to hide newly inserted content and using automated reports—reveals how app store processes themselves are vulnerable to such tactics. Given Telegram's moderation tools, Apple should have contacted the platform first to investigate and remove the material, providing proportionate accountability without disrupting millions of users. This precedent leaves platforms susceptible to co-ordinated extortion campaigns and undermines the due process necessary for fair enforcement.
Explained simply
Telegram is a messaging app where people can also join large public group chats. Pavel Durov founded the service and leads the company behind it; Apple controls which apps are available through its App Store.
The dispute centres on who can act when illegal material appears in a public chat. Durov says an attacker inserted child sexual abuse material into an older message and reported it to Apple, while Telegram’s moderation tools are intended to help identify and remove such content.
The case matters because app stores can restrict access to services, while public chat apps host material posted by users. It raises questions about how platforms and app stores respond to reports of illegal content, and how they can distinguish genuine concerns from attempts to force a takedown.
Business Companies Software Technology