News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Reform UK ‘falling to pieces in Sheffield’ after alleged coup d’état – Sheffield Tribune
Reform UK's Sheffield operation has been hit by infighting, with senior figures trading public accusations after a chaotic candidate selection meeting descended into what one insider branded a "wrecking ball" moment and others have described as an attempted coup. The row erupted at a meeting of the party's Sheffield East branch at Wadsley Bridge Working Men's Club, called to choose a candidate for the Southey council by-election on 27 August, and has since spilled into public view via social media and resignations, raising questions about the party's stability in the city just months after its local breakthrough.
The meeting turned into what was described as a "slanging match" after local party leader John Hesketh arrived, reportedly to the objection of members who favoured local candidate Mike Bell; the confrontation centred on an exchange of insults, including the phrase "fat bastard". Deputy leader John Booker has denied any coup took place, calling the affair a "massive distraction", while two councillors, Nathaniel Menday and Mick Lee, have since resigned from the party to sit as independents. Reform had won the Southey seat in May's elections as part of a 13-strong councillor intake in Sheffield, but the party has since lost councillors to resignations, including former Labour-turned-independent councillor Gareth Slater.
In short
- Reform UK Sheffield hit by infighting after chaotic candidate selection meeting
- Row centred on leader John Hesketh, insults, and a "fat bastard" jibe
- Deputy leader denies "coup"; two councillors have since quit to sit independently
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Reform UK's Sheffield operation is demonstrating worrying organisational weakness at a critical moment. The chaotic candidate selection meeting, public insults, disputed coup attempt, and resignations of multiple councillors suggest the party lacks the professional structures and mature leadership needed to manage internal disagreements constructively. If Reform cannot handle routine candidate selection without descending into acrimony and losing elected representatives, this raises legitimate questions about its readiness to govern effectively as it seeks to consolidate its recent electoral gains.
The case against
This situation is being sensationalised as a crisis when it reflects normal internal party politics. Candidate selection disputes, heated meetings, and occasional resignations occur across all political organisations, especially those experiencing rapid growth. The characterisation of a contentious meeting as an attempted 'coup' is disputed and appears hyperbolic. Reform's Sheffield breakthrough of 13 councillors in May remains a genuine electoral achievement, and internal disagreements do not undermine the party's appeal to voters or its fundamental capacity to function.
Explained simply
Reform UK is a political party whose Sheffield group won 13 council seats in local elections in May, including the Southey ward. Sheffield councillors represent local residents and make decisions about services such as housing, roads and waste collection.
The party’s local branches help choose candidates for council elections. John Hesketh leads Reform UK in Sheffield, while John Booker is the party’s deputy leader; Mike Bell was a local candidate favoured by some branch members. Disagreements over candidate selection can affect who represents the party and how it operates locally.
Two Sheffield councillors, Nathaniel Menday and Mick Lee, have left Reform UK to sit as independents, and other councillors have also left. The departures matter because they change the balance of the council and may affect the party’s ability to act as a group.