Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
Dwayne Johnson Reacts to Negative Moana Reviews After Disney’s Live-Action Remake Bombs
Dwayne Johnson has responded to poor reviews of Disney’s live-action Moana remake by saying criticism is part of working in entertainment. He emphasised that the film’s Polynesian representation and its value to children and communities mattered more to him than opening-weekend reaction, despite the remake struggling critically and commercially.
The film holds 31% from critics and 88% from audiences on Rotten Tomatoes, while IGN gave it 6/10. It opened with $95 million worldwide and had reached $261 million after four weeks, against a reported $250 million production budget; Disney nevertheless continues developing other live-action remakes, including Tangled.
In short
- Johnson accepts Moana’s poor reviews as part of the business.
- He stresses Polynesian representation over box-office performance.
- The $250 million remake has underperformed in cinemas.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The value of Polynesian representation in mainstream cinema and its positive impact on communities and children who see themselves reflected on screen transcends critical reception. Audience scores of 88% suggest viewers, particularly those from depicted communities, found genuine value in the film. Johnson's focus on cultural significance rather than critic consensus reflects a principled view that meaningful representation and audience connection matter more than critical subjectivity, which often diverges from how families actually experience film.
The case against
The stark gap between 31% critical reviews and 88% audience scores suggests significant quality issues that critics identified but audiences tolerated, raising questions about whether the film truly served its representational goals effectively. With a $250 million budget plus substantial marketing costs, the film's marginal box office performance barely justifies the investment, and Disney's continued commitment to expensive live-action remakes despite this pattern suggests resources might be better spent developing original stories or supporting emerging filmmakers from Polynesian communities.
Explained simply
Moana is a Disney story about a young Polynesian woman who sets out across the ocean to help her island community. Dwayne Johnson voices the demigod Maui in the animated film and reprises the role in the live-action version, which uses real actors and locations.
The remake has drawn mixed responses from critics and audiences, and its box-office earnings are being compared with its reported production cost. The debate also touches on how Polynesian culture is represented in a major studio film, and on Disney’s continued plans to remake animated favourites for live action.