New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
The 1985 mutiny that almost destroyed ‘Saturday Night Live’: “The show is an embarrassment”
In 1985, Saturday Night Live’s returning writer Michael O’Donoghue publicly criticised the programme, calling it “an embarrassment” and comparing it to watching old men die. His remarks followed a short, troubled return under creator Lorne Michaels and illustrated the creative turmoil that threatened to undermine the show’s relaunch.
O’Donoghue had been rehired when Michaels returned after five years away, but his plan to make short films did not come to fruition and a proposed monologue mocking host Chevy Chase was never broadcast. He was dismissed after only about a month, while the season’s inexperienced cast and uneven sketches attracted widespread criticism; most of that cast was replaced after the season.
In short
- O’Donoghue’s criticism exposed SNL’s troubled 1985 relaunch.
- His planned material was shelved before he was dismissed.
- The poorly received season prompted a major cast overhaul.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
O'Donoghue's criticism reflected objective problems with the show—the cast was demonstrably inexperienced and sketches uneven, as the near-total cast replacement confirms. He had returned with specific creative proposals that were not realised, making his frustration legitimate. When internal promises are broken and one possesses genuine expertise, public criticism can serve as necessary accountability, particularly when it catalyses the improvements the production ultimately requires.
The case against
However valid the show's shortcomings, public criticism of an ongoing production damages team morale and undermines colleagues' efforts. After only a month, O'Donoghue's assessment was premature and his inflammatory language unprofessional. His dramatic departure may have exacerbated the instability he criticised. Professional norms suggest that serious feedback merits private, constructive discussion with collaborators before public criticism, which in this case appears driven more by personal grievance over unmet promises than by commitment to collective improvement.
Explained simply
Saturday Night Live is an American live comedy programme that began in 1975. Each week, a guest host appears alongside a cast of comedians, who perform sketches and a satirical news segment. Its mix of regular performers and topical humour has made it a long-running fixture of US television.
Lorne Michaels created the programme and led its early years, then left in 1980 before returning in 1985. Michael O’Donoghue, an original writer known for dark comedy, also returned that year. The show was then trying to rebuild its cast and creative team, with actor and comedian Chevy Chase among its guest hosts.
The programme’s history helps explain why a troubled season drew attention: it was an established show trying to renew itself after a change in leadership and several years without its creator. Its later seasons continued with new casts and writers, making the 1985 period part of a wider debate about how a long-running programme adapts.