Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
4 No. 2 Songs From 1978 That We Think Deserved the Top Spot
The article argues that four singles which reached No. 2 on the US charts in 1978 were strong enough to have deserved the top position. It frames their near-misses against a chart year dominated by songs associated with Barry Gibb, while highlighting each record’s musical appeal and its artists’ wider careers.
– “Short People” by Randy Newman: a satirical song whose catchy hooks helped it become Newman’s biggest pop hit; it was held off No. 1 by Player’s “Baby Come Back” and the Bee Gees’ “Stayin’ Alive”. – “The Closer I Get To You” by Roberta Flack and Donny Hathaway: an intimate soul duet written by Reggie Lucas and James Mtume, prevented from topping the chart by Yvonne Elliman’s “If I Can’t Have You” and Wings’ “With a Little Luck”; it was among Hathaway’s final major successes before his death in 1979. – “Baker Street” by Gerry Rafferty: a solo comeback hit from the 1977 album City to City, distinguished by Raphael Ravenscroft’s saxophone riff; Andy Gibb’s “Shadow Dancing” kept it at No. 2. – “Double Vision” by Foreigner: a hard-rock crossover hit with a funk influence from the band’s 1978 album of the same name; Donna Summer’s “MacArthur Park” stopped it reaching No. 1, with Foreigner eventually achieving that milestone in 1984.
In short
- Four acclaimed 1978 singles peaked at No. 2.
- Barry Gibb-related hits dominated several chart blocks.
- Foreigner finally reached No. 1 in 1984.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
These recordings displayed superior artistic sophistication and instrumental innovation. 'Baker Street,' 'The Closer I Get to You,' 'Double Vision,' and 'Short People' each showcased distinctive instrumentation, vocal artistry, and musical risk-taking that transcended immediate commercial trends. Their enduring qualities suggest they possessed greater lasting cultural value than their chart-topping rivals.
The case against
Chart positions reflect what audiences genuinely preferred, expressed through authentic consumer choice. Arguing that other songs 'deserved' the top position applies retrospective critical standards to what people actually chose in the moment. The proper measure of what 'deserves' commercial chart success is audience preference itself, not what modern critics believe audiences should have preferred.
Explained simply
In the US, singles are ranked by how popular they are, and a song at No. 2 has come close to the top without reaching it. In 1978, four very different records did just that: Randy Newman’s satirical “Short People”, Roberta Flack and Donny Hathaway’s soul duet, Gerry Rafferty’s “Baker Street” and Foreigner’s “Double Vision”.
The artists brought different backgrounds to the songs: Newman was known for his songwriting and satire, Flack and Hathaway for their soul performances, Rafferty for his return as a solo artist, and Foreigner for blending hard rock with other styles. Their near-misses came during a year when songs linked to the Gibb brothers were especially prominent in the US charts.
The stories behind the records also reach beyond chart positions. Hathaway died in 1979, “Baker Street” is closely associated with its saxophone riff, and Foreigner later reached No. 1; together, the songs show the range of music competing for listeners in 1978.