New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
‘Room on Fire’: Why is The Strokes’ impossible 2003 follow-up still so overlooked?
The article is an opinion piece arguing that The Strokes' 2003 second album, Room on Fire, deserves far more recognition than it receives, having long been overshadowed by their acclaimed 2001 debut, Is This It. The author contends that, despite the immense pressure the band faced following the success and cultural impact of their debut, Room on Fire is actually a more confident and mature record, and may even be the band's best work, yet it continues to be unfairly dismissed as a "sophomore slump" rather than judged on its own merits.
The piece draws on a 2022 interview with producer Gordon Raphael, who worked on both albums and described the band as carrying "the weight of the world on their shoulders" after nearly two years of relentless touring following Is This It's release. Notably, the band briefly worked with Radiohead producer Nigel Godrich before scrapping those sessions and returning to Raphael, who understood their sound. Recorded in just three months, the album features tracks such as ‘What Ever Happened?’, ‘Reptilia’, ‘Under Control’ and ‘Meet Me In the Bathroom’, which the author cites as evidence of the record's enduring quality and its unfair neglect in the band's legacy.
In short
- Opinion piece argues The Strokes' Room on Fire is underrated and possibly their best
- Producer Gordon Raphael recalls immense pressure after debut Is This It's success
- Album was recorded in three months after scrapping sessions with Nigel Godrich
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Room on Fire stands as a more confident and mature achievement than its reputation suggests, with strong individual tracks demonstrating genuine artistic development. The album's relative obscurity reflects less the quality of the work itself than the impossible burden of following an iconic debut whilst the band endured exhaustion from relentless touring, meaning it deserves reassessment on its own considerable merits rather than perpetual comparison to Is This It.
The case against
Is This It's greater legacy reflects its genuine artistic and historical superiority – it was more innovative in revitalising post-punk when the genre most needed reinvigoration, and shaped the musical landscape in ways Room on Fire, though competent, never matched. Album legacies naturally develop hierarchies based on cultural impact and influence, and Room on Fire's position represents appropriate recognition of comparative achievement rather than unfair dismissal.
Explained simply
The Strokes are a New York rock band whose 2001 debut, Is This It, became one of the defining guitar albums of its era. Its success brought intense attention and expectations for whatever the band did next.
Their second album, Room on Fire, was made after nearly two years of touring. The band worked with producer Gordon Raphael, who had helped shape the debut’s sound, after briefly recording with producer Nigel Godrich. The album includes songs such as “Reptilia” and “What Ever Happened?”
The debate around the record centres on how it compares with the celebrated debut and how that comparison has shaped its reputation. Understanding that context helps explain why listeners and critics continue to reassess its place in the band’s catalogue.