New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
“I don’t think the underground or extreme metal scene will ever dig us. It’s elitist”: How Trivium defied the gatekeepers and split the critics with The Crusade
Trivium broke through in 2005 with their album Ascendancy and a star-making performance at Download festival, but their 2006 follow-up, The Crusade, prompted a significant backlash and divided critics and fans. Metal Hammer spoke to the band during their first US tour that year, discussing their rapid success, accusations of snobbery from parts of the scene, and support they received from some of metal's biggest names.
The band reflected candidly on the gatekeeping culture within underground and extreme metal, with a member stating bluntly that they don't believe that scene will ever accept Trivium, branding it "elitist". The piece, framed with a vivid desert-set narrative device, revisits the making of The Crusade and the pressures the band faced following their sudden rise to prominence in the metal world.
In short
- Trivium's 2006 album The Crusade split critics after their Ascendancy breakthrough.
- Band felt snubbed by an "elitist" underground/extreme metal scene.
- 2006 Metal Hammer interview covered success, snobbery and peer support.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Trivium's evolution and commercial success represent legitimate artistic growth that metal should welcome without gatekeeping. Talented musicians should be encouraged to develop their craft and reach broader audiences, and dismissing their work simply for greater accessibility is elitist gatekeeping that stifles creativity. A genre benefits from inclusivity and new listeners, not from insular underground circles that demand rigid adherence to tradition.
The case against
Metal's distinctive underground traditions embody specific sonic and cultural values worth preserving, and when bands abandon rawer, more extreme characteristics for commercial polish, something genuine is lost. Fans and critics who value metal's distinctive identity are not being elitist gatekeepers; they are defending what makes the genre meaningful and distinct. Legitimate artistic criticism of significant stylistic shifts is fair assessment, not unfair gatekeeping of creative expression.
Explained simply
Trivium are a heavy metal band who rose to wider attention with their 2005 album Ascendancy and a prominent appearance at Download festival. Their next album, The Crusade, came out in 2006, as the band were touring the United States and adjusting to sudden success.
Metal has many styles and communities, including underground and extreme metal, where some listeners and musicians value less mainstream sounds. Trivium’s rapid rise brought questions about whether the band would be accepted by those parts of the scene, while established metal acts also offered them support.
The response to The Crusade was divided among critics and fans, making it a significant moment in the band’s early career. The story looks back at the album and the arguments about musical taste, scene boundaries and who gets recognised in metal.