Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
This Earl Thomas Conley Hit From 1983 Was Inspired by a Simon & Garfunkel Classic
Country singer Earl Thomas Conley's 1983 hit "Holding Her And Loving You" was structurally inspired by Simon & Garfunkel's "Bridge Over Troubled Water", according to co-writer Walt Aldridge. The song, one of only two on Conley's album Don't Make It Easy On Me that he did not write himself, tackles infidelity through an unconventional structure of several verses without a chorus, a choice Aldridge says helped it stand out amid competing songs pitched at the time.
Aldridge, who wrote the track with Tom Brasfield, told The Tennessean he had long admired older songs built around closing refrains rather than choruses, citing Simon & Garfunkel's classic as a key influence. The writing session was sparked by Brasfield's opening line "It's the third hardest thing I'll ever do", prompting Aldridge to add "Leaving here without you" and build a "countdown" structure around the song's central dilemma of a man torn between two women. Aldridge credited Conley's emotive vocal performance, alongside producer Nelson Larkin, with elevating the song into one of the singer's biggest hits.
In short
- Conley's 1983 hit borrowed its chorus-free structure from "Bridge Over Troubled Water".
- Co-writer Walt Aldridge revealed the song's unusual "countdown" opening line origin.
- Aldridge credited Conley's heartfelt vocal delivery for the song's lasting success.
Explained simply
Earl Thomas Conley was an American country singer whose 1983 album Don’t Make It Easy On Me included “Holding Her And Loving You”. Conley did not write the song; it was written by Nashville songwriters Walt Aldridge and Tom Brasfield.
The song tells of a man torn between two women and uses several verses without a chorus. Aldridge said he and Brasfield drew on older songs that build towards a closing refrain, especially Simon & Garfunkel’s “Bridge Over Troubled Water”.
That structure helped the song stand apart from others being pitched to country performers at the time. Aldridge also credited Conley’s vocal performance and producer Nelson Larkin with helping make it a major hit.