8 Greatest Remakes of Classic Horror Movies
This Collider article ranks the eight greatest remakes of classic horror films, arguing that while remakes are often viewed cynically as cash-grabs, a select few match or surpass their originals when placed in capable hands. Written by Joe Leone, the piece pushes back against blanket scepticism towards horror remakes by highlighting films that successfully reinterpreted beloved source material rather than simply trading on name recognition.
Topping the excerpt are Fede Alvarez's 2013 "Evil Dead", praised for abandoning much of the original's campy horror-comedy tone in favour of pure, unrelenting terror, and Chuck Russell's 1988 "The Blob", noted for exceeding its 1958 predecessor with memorable body-horror effects. The full list of eight includes other notable remakes, though Alexandre Aja's "The Hills Have Eyes" and both Nosferatu remakes were noted as strong contenders that narrowly missed inclusion.
In short
- Collider ranks the eight best horror movie remakes ever made
- 2013's "Evil Dead" praised for prioritising genuine scares over comedy
- 1988's "The Blob" cited for surpassing the 1958 original's effects
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Remakes in capable hands can offer valuable new interpretations of source material, updating classics for contemporary audiences whilst improving on technical limitations of the originals. When driven by genuine artistic vision rather than mere nostalgia exploitation, remakes represent a legitimate form of creative cinema that can match or exceed their predecessors, expanding the possibilities of beloved stories rather than simply recycling them.
The case against
The proliferation of horror remakes reflects studio cynicism and commercial calculation rather than artistic ambition, prioritising established brand recognition over original storytelling. Regardless of occasional successes, remakes divert resources and industry attention from new voices and innovative ideas, fundamentally representing creative bankruptcy that values profit margins over genuine cinematic achievement.
Explained simply
A horror remake retells a story that has already been made into a film, often using newer filmmaking techniques or a different tone. The originals discussed here include The Blob, first released in 1958, and Evil Dead, a low-budget horror film from 1981.
Remakes can draw on audiences’ familiarity with an older film, but they also give directors room to reinterpret its story and style. The films mentioned here include versions by directors Fede Alvarez and Chuck Russell, whose approaches differed from those of the original filmmakers.
The debate is whether a remake can stand on its own as well as honour its source. Looking at the films side by side helps explain why some are welcomed as fresh takes while others face scepticism.