News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Wrong forms given out in solar farm consultation
Residents in Rotherham and Doncaster were given incorrect paper forms for responding to proposals for the Whitestone Solar Farm, meaning their feedback could not be accepted by the Planning Inspectorate. The error prompted concern among local groups that residents’ statutory right to take part in the consultation had been undermined, particularly as it emerged just before the original deadline.
Developer One Nation said staff had supplied the forms to help people without email addresses register and submit comments by post, based on their understanding of the guidance. The Inspectorate said valid representations must be made online or using an official paper form obtained from it; the developer has extended the registration deadline to 11 September. If approved, the nationally significant project would reportedly power about 250,000 homes and be larger than Europe’s biggest operational solar farm.
In short
- Incorrect consultation forms meant some residents’ feedback could not be accepted.
- Developer extended the deadline to 11 September.
- Proposed solar farm could power around 250,000 homes.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The developer’s forms were intended to help residents without email access take part by post, and staff may have supplied them in good faith based on their understanding of the guidance. Extending the deadline gives affected residents more time to register, while the project could provide substantial low-carbon electricity if approved.
The case against
Residents need a clear, workable way to exercise their statutory right to comment, and forms that the Planning Inspectorate cannot accept risk excluding people from the process. Because the problem surfaced close to the original deadline, local groups can reasonably question whether the extension fully repairs the disruption or restores confidence in the consultation.
Explained simply
Whitestone is a proposed large solar farm in South Yorkshire, spanning areas of Rotherham and Doncaster. Its developer, One Nation, is seeking consent for the project, which would generate electricity from solar panels and connect to the power network.
Because of its size, the proposal is considered a nationally significant infrastructure project. The Planning Inspectorate manages the examination process and sets how people can submit formal comments, known as representations. These rules matter because the Inspectorate can only consider comments made through the accepted channels.
Local residents and groups have raised concerns about access to the consultation, especially for people who rely on post rather than email. The project’s scale also means its potential contribution to electricity supply is part of the public discussion.