NYC woman, 49, seen waving two huge knives at cops in Times Square shortly before she was shot dead for stabbing two people at random
Developed over time first seen 2 months ago
A woman armed with two kitchen knives stabbed two people at random in Times Square, New York, before being shot dead by police after refusing to drop her weapons despite being tasered. Erin Piacenti, 32, a Bank of America vice president from Chester, New Jersey, died from a stab wound to the abdomen, while a 68-year-old man was also knifed in the stomach and remains in stable condition in hospital. The attack briefly sparked panic in the crowded tourist hub before officers, praised by city officials for preventing further casualties, confronted and killed the attacker.
The attacker was identified as Pamela Cisneros Lopez, 49, of Queens, who police said had a "documented mental health history" including two prior incidents in 2018 and 2019, though she had never been arrested. During a standoff, Lopez reportedly told officers "I'm not dropping anything, I would rather kill both of you" before running at them and being shot. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch and Mayor Zohran Mamdani both credited the officers' actions with averting further bloodshed in what Tisch called "the crossroads of the world," and investigators believe Lopez, described as emotionally disturbed, had no clear motive for the seemingly random attack.
- Woman stabbed two people at random in Times Square, New York
- Attacker Pamela Cisneros Lopez, 49, shot dead after refusing to drop knives
- Victim Erin Piacenti, 32, died; second victim, 68, stable in hospital
New here? Start with this
Pamela Cisneros Lopez, a 49-year-old woman from Queens with a documented history of mental health problems, was shot dead by New York police on Monday in Times Square. She had stabbed two strangers at random, killing a 32-year-old woman and wounding a 68-year-old man, before advancing on officers with two large kitchen knives despite being tasered.
Times Square is one of New York's busiest tourist and commercial areas, so an attack there carries particular weight, both for public safety and for the city's image. Lopez had two prior police encounters, in 2018 and 2019, but had never been arrested, and officials say there is no sign the attack was terrorism-related.
The case has drawn attention to how police handle confrontations involving people in mental health crisis, and to the wider debate in New York over street safety and policing tactics. Investigators are still trying to establish what led Lopez to carry out the attack.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of the police response argue that officers faced an active and ongoing lethal threat: a woman who had already fatally stabbed one bystander and wounded another at random, and who explicitly told officers she would rather kill them than surrender. They note that officers first attempted a non-lethal option, tasering her, and only resorted to firearms when she continued advancing with two large knives through a crowded public square. From this view, officers had seconds to prevent further deaths and cannot be expected to accept unlimited personal risk, or risk to bystanders, once de-escalation has visibly failed.
The case against
Others focused on this case argue it illustrates a wider, systemic problem: that society and law enforcement remain poorly equipped to intervene with people experiencing acute mental health crises before violence occurs. They point to Lopez's documented psychiatric history and two prior police contacts in 2018 and 2019, none resulting in arrest, as evidence that earlier opportunities for treatment or intervention may have been missed. This perspective does not necessarily fault the officers' split-second decision in the final confrontation, but calls for greater investment in specialised crisis-response teams and mental health infrastructure so that such encounters are less likely to escalate to a fatal police shooting in the first place.