Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Profits, Prophets, Coaches and Kings by Jared Diamond review – how to change the course of history
Jared Diamond's new book asks whether prominent individuals genuinely shape history, or whether others would have achieved similar results in their place, using a self-styled "Hamlet test" to judge cases from Shakespeare to African statesmen to business tycoons. The review, published in the Guardian, is largely critical, arguing that Diamond's central test is flawed from the outset and that the book ignores decades of existing scholarship in history, ethics and business studies while presenting its questions as novel.
The reviewer challenges Diamond's Shakespeare example by noting that Christopher Marlowe, killed in 1593 aged 29, had already produced major works and may have rivalled Shakespeare had he lived longer, undermining Diamond's claim of "unique talent". More favourably, the review credits Diamond's use of "natural experiments" — such as economists comparing New Jersey and Pennsylvania fast-food employment after a minimum-wage rise, or studies estimating CEOs account for 6-29% of company earnings variation and coaches up to 30% of team performance — as a genuinely interesting method, even as it grows shakier when applied to murkier proxies like UN parking fines as a stand-in for corruption.
In short
- Guardian review is critical of Jared Diamond's new book on influential individuals.
- Diamond's "Hamlet test" is challenged using the counterexample of Christopher Marlowe.
- Book's use of "natural experiments" (wages, CEOs, coaches) is praised as its best feature.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Diamond’s question is worth asking because history can turn on individuals whose choices, abilities or leadership change what happens next. His use of natural experiments offers a way to test that influence rather than assume it, and the examples involving wages, executives and coaches suggest that individuals can make a measurable difference in some settings.
The case against
The reviewer’s strongest objection is that Diamond’s test may not establish whether a person was truly irreplaceable: Marlowe’s early work, for instance, leaves open what he might have achieved had he lived. The book also risks treating long-debated questions as new while overlooking relevant scholarship, and its estimates become less persuasive when clear comparisons give way to uncertain proxies such as parking fines.
Explained simply
Jared Diamond’s book examines how much individuals influence the course of history. It asks whether a different person in the same position might have achieved much the same result, considering figures such as Shakespeare, African statesmen, business leaders and sports coaches.
One way the book explores this question is through “natural experiments”: comparisons between places or organisations that can help estimate the effect of a particular change or leader. The reviewer finds this approach interesting in some cases, but questions whether it can answer broader questions about individual influence.
The debate matters because it concerns how history is explained: through exceptional people, or through circumstances and forces that might have produced similar outcomes anyway. The review also places Diamond’s argument against existing work in history, ethics and business studies.