News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Lord Blunkett ‘deeply’ regrets his Hillsborough response
Lord Blunkett has told the House of Lords that he "deeply" regrets not doing more to support Hillsborough families during his time as home secretary, saying the decades-long campaign for the Hillsborough Law could have been resolved far sooner had politicians taken more responsibility at the time. The Labour peer, who represented Sheffield Brightside, the constituency covering Hillsborough Stadium, when the 1989 disaster killed 97 people, made the admission during a Lords debate on the Public Office (Accountability) Bill, which is designed to compel public officials to tell the truth during investigations and inquiries.
Lord Blunkett, who was home secretary from 2001 to 2004, said he had been reflecting for the past year or two on whether he could have done more, adding that he was "grateful" he had not believed police accounts of the disaster, unlike some fellow MPs. He praised bereaved families' "incredible tenacity" in pursuing the truth, noting that fresh inquests in 2016 found the victims were unlawfully killed and that police had contributed to their deaths. The bill, which completed its Commons stages in July and had its Lords second reading this week, would introduce a legal duty of candour for public bodies and expand legal aid for bereaved families, having previously been delayed by disputes over whether intelligence agencies should be covered.
In short
- Blunkett regrets not doing more for Hillsborough families as home secretary
- Hillsborough Law bill had its second reading in the Lords this week
- Bill would create legal duty of candour for public officials
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A statutory duty of candour could help prevent public bodies from withholding or distorting information in serious investigations, and give bereaved families a fairer chance to uncover the truth. The long campaign after Hillsborough, and Lord Blunkett’s regret that politicians did not act sooner, support the case for clear legal obligations and better access to legal aid.
The case against
A new legal duty and expanded legal aid could add complexity and cost to investigations, and may risk encouraging defensive, formulaic disclosures rather than candid cooperation. Any law must also be carefully defined so it protects sensitive information, including national security material, while ensuring officials can still make sound decisions under scrutiny.
Explained simply
The Hillsborough disaster happened in 1989, when a fatal crowd crush at a football match killed 97 people. Many of the victims’ families spent decades seeking answers about how the disaster happened and whether public authorities had told the truth.
David Blunkett was the Labour MP for Sheffield Brightside, which includes Hillsborough, and later served as home secretary from 2001 to 2004. Fresh inquests in 2016 concluded that the victims had been unlawfully killed and that police failures contributed to their deaths.
The Hillsborough Law is the name given to proposed legislation intended to make public officials more accountable during investigations and inquiries. The bill would require public bodies to be candid and would widen access to legal aid for bereaved families.