World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
UK’s Online Safety Act has made ‘absolutely no difference,’ kids say
England's Children's Commissioner, Dame Rachel de Souza, has told a House of Lords committee that children say the Online Safety Act has made "absolutely no difference" to their ability to access harmful content, more than a year after its key child protection duties took effect. Speaking at the opening evidence session of the Lords Communications and Digital Committee's inquiry into the Act, she criticised its focus on moderating content rather than tackling harmful platform design, and said there was no evidence it had meaningfully changed how social media firms operate, contrasting this with recent US legal pressure that pushed Meta towards child safety concessions.
De Souza pointed to Meta's proposed $18 billion US settlement, which would introduce two-hour daily limits for under-18s on Facebook and Instagram, anti-scrolling prompts, restrictions during school hours and at night, and the option to opt out of algorithmic feeds, arguing the OSA had "not been flexible enough" to keep pace. She also revealed Ofcom had refused to share tech companies' safety risk assessments with her, despite her safeguarding role, and said she would use statutory powers to compel disclosure while asking the committee for support, citing section 393(1) of the Communications Act 2003 as the legal obstacle. She said Ofcom needed to "use its teeth," while acknowledging its recent action on the Grok "nudifying" controversy and pornography age-verification investigations.
In short
- Children say Online Safety Act hasn't reduced access to harmful content
- Commissioner faults OSA for ignoring addictive platform design features
- Ofcom refusing to share risk assessments; commissioner plans to compel disclosure
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The Act’s defenders can argue that it establishes enforceable duties and gives Ofcom powers to press platforms to assess risks and improve safeguards, so its effects may take time to show. They may also see the law’s focus on illegal and harmful content as a practical starting point, while recognising that design changes and new online risks require continued regulatory action.
The case against
Critics can argue that children’s reported experience is evidence the Act has not yet delivered meaningful protection, and that removing individual items of content leaves harmful design features such as algorithmic feeds and compulsive scrolling largely intact. They may say a framework that cannot keep pace with platforms or share risk assessments with a safeguarding commissioner needs stronger enforcement and greater transparency.
Explained simply
The Online Safety Act sets rules for online services, including duties to assess risks to children and protect them from illegal and harmful material. Ofcom, the communications regulator, is responsible for enforcing the rules, while the Children’s Commissioner for England represents and promotes children’s interests.
Dame Rachel de Souza has raised concerns about whether the Act addresses the way platforms are designed, as well as the content they host. This matters because design features can affect what children see and how they use services, while Ofcom’s safety risk assessments help show how companies identify and respond to risks.