Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The 8 Best Books You Probably Had To Read in High School, Ranked
Collider has published a ranked list of eight books commonly assigned in US high school English classes, arguing that despite their reputation as reluctant reading, many remain genuinely worthwhile and could be worth revisiting as an adult. The piece frames the selection around books that are frequently set as classroom texts, noting these can often be spotted by their unusually high vote counts but comparatively modest average ratings on sites such as Goodreads.
Only part of the ranking is detailed here, with three entries discussed: Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is praised as one of the more readable classics of its age, valued for exploring timeless themes of humanity, life and death; S.E. Hinton's The Outsiders is highlighted for its authenticity, having been written by Hinton as a teenager, giving it lasting appeal to young readers; and F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby is described as a quintessential, symbolism-heavy work that remains divisive among readers who consider it overrated, despite its enduring status as a set text.
In short
- Collider ranks eight books commonly assigned in high school English classes.
- Frankenstein praised for readability and enduring philosophical themes.
- The Outsiders and The Great Gatsby cited as classic, if divisive, staples.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Frequently assigned books can introduce students to lasting questions about humanity, identity and society, while giving them shared texts to discuss and interpret. Frankenstein, The Outsiders and The Great Gatsby show how classics and more immediate stories can remain meaningful beyond the classroom, making them worth revisiting as adults.
The case against
Making these books compulsory can turn potentially engaging stories into assignments students associate with pressure and close analysis, rather than reading for pleasure. Their lasting reputation does not guarantee that every text will connect with every pupil, and some readers may reasonably find celebrated works such as The Great Gatsby overrated or less rewarding than other choices.
Explained simply
In the US, high school English classes often study novels and plays chosen for their literary influence, themes or historical context. Some of these books are widely read in school but divide opinion among students and later readers.
Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein explores humanity, life and death through the story of a scientist and the being he creates. S.E. Hinton wrote The Outsiders as a teenager, and its portrayal of young people has helped it remain popular with students. F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby is known for its symbolism and is still frequently taught, though readers differ on its merits.
These works matter because they have shaped how generations encounter classic literature in school. Reading them as adults can bring different perspectives, while their continued place in classrooms keeps debate alive about what students should study.