World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Laura Poitras Shares the Desperate Vision Behind Her ICE Documentary ‘They’re Here’: “What’s Happening in the United States Is a Nightmare”
Filmmaker Laura Poitras, speaking at the Venice Film Festival, has described the making of her new short documentary "They're Here" as an urgent response to what she calls a "nightmare" of normalised violence under ICE's immigration crackdown in the United States. The 25-minute film, co-directed with Minneapolis journalist Rachel Lauren Mueller, uses dashcam footage, crowdsourced data and dystopian-style visuals to depict last year's paramilitary-style ICE operation in Minneapolis and the local resistance movement that sprang up against it, aiming to make audiences feel the "terror" of events rather than simply intellectualise them.
Poitras, an Oscar winner for "Citizenfour" and Golden Lion winner for "All the Beauty and the Bloodshed", said the project grew from solidarity with immigrant neighbours in Minneapolis. She cited the resistance as a "great success", noting ICE withdrew roughly 80% of its agents in response to public pushback, while warning that the agency's $70 billion budget and a reported 90,000 detentions in June and July show enforcement remains intense, just with different tactics. The film premieres in Venice's Out of Competition strand, produced by Mueller, Poitras and Yoni Golijov with ARTE France co-producing.
In short
- Poitras's ICE documentary "They're Here" premieres at Venice Film Festival
- Film depicts Minneapolis resistance to 2025 ICE operation using dystopian visuals
- Poitras cites $70bn ICE budget and 90,000 recent detentions as ongoing concern
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of Poitras’s approach could argue that an urgent, emotionally forceful film is justified when communities experience aggressive enforcement and its effects risk becoming normalised. By documenting events and local resistance, the film may help audiences understand the human stakes and recognise how collective action can influence policy.
The case against
A reasonable critic could argue that a film designed to make viewers feel terror risks privileging emotional impact over context, especially when presenting a contested law-enforcement operation through a resistance movement’s perspective. They might also question whether claims about the operation’s effects and ICE’s withdrawal are sufficiently scrutinised, and favour reporting that examines enforcement aims, evidence and competing accounts alongside community testimony.
Explained simply
US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is the federal agency that enforces immigration laws, including detaining people suspected of being in the country unlawfully. Its operations can affect immigrants and their neighbours, and have prompted protests in communities across the United States.
Laura Poitras is a US documentary filmmaker known for films about surveillance and political power. For this film, she worked with Minneapolis journalist Rachel Lauren Mueller, drawing on footage and information gathered by local residents to show an ICE operation and the community response around it.
Americas Business Entertainment Film Horror Markets World