Full account

Israel has retaliated against Britain's decision to impose trade sanctions on goods from Jewish settlements in the occupied West Bank by shutting its consulate in East Jerusalem and severing several strands of diplomatic and military cooperation with London. The sanctions were unveiled in the House of Commons by Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband, who accused the Israeli government of enabling what he described as the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians by extremist settlers and pointed to mounting evidence of war crimes in Gaza. He said Britain could not stand by while the expansion of settlements, including a contested scheme for 1,200 homes east of Jerusalem that would effectively split the West Bank, undermined any remaining prospect of a two-state solution.

Israel's Foreign Minister, Gideon Sa'ar, denounced the announcement as 'outrageous lies' and said he had consulted Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu before ordering a package of countermeasures. As well as closing the East Jerusalem consulate, Israel has excluded British forces from the International Gaza Support Centre, which coordinates ceasefire and peacebuilding operations in the Strip alongside American and Israeli personnel, and has ended UK-led training of Palestinian Authority security forces in the West Bank. Sa'ar also barred a dozen British politicians from entering Israel, including former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn, Diane Abbott, John McDonnell, Zarah Sultana and all five Green MPs, citing what he called anti-Semitic and anti-Israel conduct. He argued that Britain's move was especially perverse given London's historic role in the Balfour Declaration, and accused Labour of improperly interfering in Israel's forthcoming general election.

The timing and framing of the announcement, made in the run-up to the Jewish New Year, provoked a sharp backlash from British Jewish organisations and figures across the political spectrum. Chief Rabbi Sir Ephraim Mirvis called it 'a dark day for British Jews', warning that what he characterised as gesture politics risked emboldening those who use hatred as a weapon against Jewish people at home and abroad. The Board of Deputies of British Jews said it had repeatedly warned ministers, including Andy Burnham, that the policy could carry unintended consequences and further strain communal security, coming so soon after last year's terror attack near a synagogue in Manchester. Labour peer Lord Mendelsohn and Conservative peer Lord Polak both criticised Miliband personally, objecting in particular to his description of himself as a 'proud Jew' when setting out the sanctions, while Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch accused the government of risking a rise in anti-Semitism to win back voters drifting to the Greens.

The fallout has also raised concerns about Britain's wider standing and security. Officials are said to have warned ministers before the announcement that isolating settlement produce from the rest of Israeli trade would be practically very difficult, and the government's National Security Adviser reportedly cautioned that the move could damage key alliances. There is particular unease that Israel might scale back intelligence sharing through Mossad, which has helped foil terrorist plots in the UK, at a time when the domestic threat level remains severe. Washington has also signalled displeasure, with the US ambassador to Israel warning of likely reprisals, potentially including trade restrictions from individual American states. Questions have additionally been raised over why the sanctions were announced weeks before Israeli elections rather than after them, given the six-to-nine-month timeframe needed for implementation, since a change of government in Israel could alter the settlement policies at the heart of the dispute.

Where outlets differ

Source 1 (focused on Jewish community reaction) foregrounds the anger of Chief Rabbi Mirvis, Lord Mendelsohn, Lord Polak and the Board of Deputies over the timing before Rosh Hashanah and the reference to the Heaton Park synagogue attack, and questions why the announcement pre-empted Israeli elections.

Source 2 concentrates on Israel's retaliatory measures in detail — the consulate closure, expulsion from the Gaza support centre, the MP travel ban list, and Sa'ar's invocation of the Balfour Declaration — and flags the risk to Mossad intelligence-sharing and Britain's diminished diplomatic footprint.

Source 3 gives most weight to Miliband's own justification for the sanctions (allegations of 'ethnic cleansing' and 'war crimes') and to domestic political criticism from Kemi Badenoch, plus practical objections from officials and the anticipated US reaction via ambassador Mike Huckabee.

• www.dailymail.com
• www.dailymail.com
• www.dailymail.com