World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
LIZ PEEK: We cannot let the left rewrite what happened on 9/11
Fox News opinion writer Liz Peek argues that Americans must not allow the political left to downplay or reframe the 11 September 2001 terrorist attacks as the 25th anniversary approaches. She singles out Rep. Ilhan Omar's remark that "some people did something" as an attempt to obscure the fact that Islamist terrorists deliberately killed thousands of Americans, and insists the historical record of who carried out the attacks and why must be preserved.
Peek recounts her own memories of the day as a New York resident, including her daughters' fear that the attacks had struck their father's nearby office, colleagues escaping the debris and ash-covered chaos, and the citywide fear of further strikes in the weeks that followed, when 2,977 people were confirmed killed. She also describes the New York Philharmonic's Brahms Requiem performance weeks later, attended by then-Mayor Rudy Giuliani and Governor George Pataki, as a symbol of a city and country forever changed by the attacks.
In short
- Opinion piece marks 25th anniversary of 9/11, rejects attempts to minimise the attacks
- Author recalls personal memories of the day and its aftermath in New York
- Criticises Rep. Ilhan Omar's past remarks as downplaying terrorist responsibility
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A thoughtful case for Peek’s argument is that remembering 9/11 accurately means naming the deliberate actions of al-Qaeda and the scale of the harm, rather than using vague language that could make the perpetrators or their motives less clear. Preserving that record honours the victims and helps future generations understand why the attacks shaped American life and policy.
The case against
A thoughtful counterargument is that resisting political reframing should apply across the political spectrum, and that a remark such as “some people did something” may be criticised without treating it as evidence that the left broadly seeks to rewrite 9/11. Public memory can state plainly who carried out the attacks while also making room to examine how the tragedy has been invoked in later political debates.
Explained simply
On 11 September 2001, members of al-Qaeda hijacked four passenger planes in the United States. Two were flown into the World Trade Centre in New York, one hit the Pentagon near Washington, and the fourth crashed in Pennsylvania after passengers fought back; 2,977 people were killed.
The attacks led to a US-led campaign against al-Qaeda and the Taliban government in Afghanistan, as well as major changes to security and foreign policy. They remain a subject of public debate, including how the attacks and their causes are described, and what lessons should be remembered.