World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Company’ Review: Casey Affleck’s Latest Directorial Effort Isn’t What It Initially Appears to Be, but Isn’t Very Interesting Either Way
Casey Affleck's second feature as writer-director, "Company," premiered in competition at the Venice Film Festival but has left critics unconvinced, with Variety's review calling it a "perversely ponderous exercise in hide-the-genre" that takes over an hour to reveal its true nature. The film disguises itself as a folk-flavoured meditation on storytelling before shifting into genre territory via a twist that critics found underwhelming and slow to arrive, making it a difficult prospect for any distributor considering picking it up.
The story unfolds across three nested timelines, each involving a mysterious stranger unsettling a household: in 1975, a young woman named Evelyn (Emily Alyn Lind) turns up at a Christmas party and begins telling a story; that story, set in 1953, features widower Tom (Nick Nolte) and stranger Alice (Caylee Cowan); which in turn nests a tale from 1903 about farming couple Rebecca (Adelaide Clemens) and Emmett (Scoot McNairy), who take in a drifter, Caleb, played by Affleck's own teenage son, Atticus. The review notes the film echoes the revisionist Western tone of Affleck's earlier acting work and was co-written with Ron Hansen, but ultimately finds the layered structure tedious and the pacing "molasses," concluding it falls short of Affleck's 2019 directorial debut, "Light of My Life."
In short
- Casey Affleck's "Company" premiered in Venice's main competition to muted reviews.
- Nested three-era stories hide a genre twist critics found dull and unearned.
- Affleck's teenage son Atticus stars; Nick Nolte also features.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The nested timelines and delayed shift in genre could be read as a deliberate experiment in how stories unsettle people, asking viewers to sit with ambiguity before their expectations change. Its measured pace and revisionist Western atmosphere may appeal to audiences who value mood, structure and gradual revelation over brisk plotting.
The case against
The same choices may make the film feel needlessly opaque: withholding its genre for more than an hour risks frustrating viewers without making the eventual turn rewarding. If the layered stories move too slowly and the twist feels underwhelming, the formal ambition may not compensate for a tedious experience or help the film find an audience.
Explained simply
Company is a film written and directed by Casey Affleck, who is also known as an actor. It is his second feature as a director, following Light of My Life, and was co-written with novelist Ron Hansen.
The film links three stories set in 1903, 1953 and 1975. In each, a mysterious stranger enters a household: the later stories frame the earlier ones, as people tell tales to one another.
The cast includes Nick Nolte, Scoot McNairy and Affleck’s son Atticus. The film’s layered storytelling and shift into genre territory are central to how critics have assessed it, and may affect whether a distributor chooses to release it.
Americas Business Companies Fitness Health World