World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
David Lynch’s ambitious plan to reshape American film censorship: “There should be another rating”
David Lynch once pushed for an overhaul of American film censorship after his 1986 film Blue Velvet was hit with an X-rating by the Motion Picture Association (MPA), a classification he felt unfairly lumped serious cinema in with pornography. Lynch argued the rating stemmed not from the film's nudity, sex or violence but from certain scenes being deemed "too powerful" — precisely the emotional impact he had intended, prompting him to propose a new tier of certification. His complaint reflects a long-running debate over whether film censorship protects audiences or stifles artistic expression, with the MPA and Britain's BBFC gradually loosening restrictions on adult content over the decades.
Lynch suggested introducing a "Double R" rating, positioned between a hard R and an X, which would still allow films to be advertised in newspapers, unlike X-rated releases, which were often shunned by theatres and publications. His idea was echoed in 1990 when the MPA created the NC-17 rating, distinguishing mature, non-pornographic content from explicit material. Notably, Blue Velvet is now classified even lower than NC-17, carrying just an R rating under today's standards.
In short
- Lynch objected to Blue Velvet's 1986 X-rating from the MPA.
- He proposed a new "Double R" certification between R and X.
- MPA introduced the similar NC-17 rating in 1990.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A distinct adult rating could help audiences make informed choices while allowing serious films with challenging material to reach cinemas and be advertised. Supporters would argue that clear, graduated classifications protect younger viewers without treating artistic exploration of sex, violence or disturbing themes as equivalent to pornography.
The case against
Ratings can help parents and audiences judge whether content is suitable, and a new category may make boundaries harder to understand without changing the underlying judgement calls. Those favouring stricter or simpler classifications could also argue that wider advertising and distribution for mature material may expose younger audiences to it, so clear limits serve a legitimate protective purpose.
Explained simply
American films are classified by the Motion Picture Association (MPA), which rates them for age suitability. In the 1980s, an X rating generally meant that under-17s could not attend, but it also made a film difficult to advertise and could lead cinemas to avoid showing it.
David Lynch was a filmmaker whose 1986 film Blue Velvet included disturbing and sexual material. He argued that an X rating wrongly grouped serious adult films with pornography, and proposed a “Double R” category to distinguish them. The debate reflects a wider tension between giving audiences guidance and allowing filmmakers to portray challenging subjects.
In 1990, the MPA introduced NC-17 for films intended for adults, separating that category from X-rated releases. Film ratings have since changed, and Blue Velvet now carries an R rating in the United States.
Americas Entertainment Film World